Luxury rentals in Eleuthera

Home in North Eleuthra

Middle Cay

Take a bottle of wine down to the beach and watch the Caribbean sunset from your own private island in the Bahamas. When the sun disappears, make your way to the hot tub for a little stargazing with that special someone. Before bed, join the group around the campfire for one more s’more. Wander Middle Cay’s 2-acre estate to find coconut tree groves, private beachfront, and 2 private docks. Accommodations are split between 2 air-conditioned, open-concept villas, making this island perfect for multi-family getaways and group vacations. Warm wood tones, stone features, and ocean-inspired turquoise create a modern, natural vibe inside. During your stay, you’ll enjoy daily housekeeping and the assistance of a boat captain. Outside, palm trees, sun loungers, and lush tropical greenery decorate the multiple lounges, dining areas, and pool deck. After a trip to the local market, spend the afternoon grilling on the barbecue while the kids play beach volleyball. Book a surfing lesson in Eleuthra or check out Ocean Hole, a natural inland swimming spot. The crystal clear waters make it easy to spot bright tropical fish, and maybe even a sea turtle or two. Later, hop in a water taxi and head for Dunmore Town to find a favorite new restaurant. If you’d rather catch your own dinner, Middle Cay comes with fishing gear, a canoe, and a sailboat. Copyright © Luxury Retreats. All rights reserved. BEDROOM & BATHROOM Main House • Bedroom 1 - Primary: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Dual vanity, Air conditioning, Terrace, Ocean view • Bedroom 2: 2 Double size beds, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone rain shower, Air conditioning • Bedroom 3: 2 Twin size beds, Access to hallway bathroom with stand-alone shower, Air conditioning • Bedroom 4: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Air conditioning Cottage • Bedroom 5: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone rain shower, Air conditioning, Balcony • Bedroom 6: 2 Double size beds, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone rain shower, Air conditioning Additional Bedding • Bedroom 7: Twin size bunk bed, Trundle bed, Access to hallway half bathroom, Air conditioning, Balcony FEATURES & AMENITIES OUTDOOR FEATURES • Private dock • Terrace • Beach volleyball • Outdoor living area • 3 Underwater sea scooters • Boat - 16 passengers (fuel at extra cost) • More under “What this place offers” below STAFF & SERVICES Included: • Boat captain • Serving staff Extra cost (advance notice may be required): • Boat fuel and oil • Massage therapist • Activities and excursions

Wind Whistle

Watch the sunset over the Caribbean at this colonial villa on the waterfront of Dunmore Town, in Harbour Island. Outlined in lush greenery, your dinner parties and backyard barbecues will enjoy complete privacy, as well as spectacular ocean views. Sip a tropical cocktail in the shade while the kids play on the private dock’s water trampoline. Then, hop in a golf cart and explore nearby beaches. Enter through the private gates and follow a tree-lined driveway leading up to this traditional Bahamian home on the ocean’s edge. Wrap-around balconies, white-washed interiors, and four-post beds await in this stately, colonial environment. Inside, coffered-ceilings sit atop hardwood floors and designer furnishings. Playful floral prints add a splash of exciting color to the soothing atmosphere, reminding guests of the natural hues outside. Pick a sunny spot to work on your tan by the pool. When you need to cool off, jump off the end of the private dock and enjoy the cool waters of the Caribbean. If you’re in the to mood explore, the villa comes with 2 paddle boards and 2 kayaks. Famous for its colorful sand, Pink Sands Beach is the perfect place to start your morning with a yoga session, swim, or a stroll. After, stop in for breakfast at a cafe on Princess Street. While you’re there, check out local works of art at the Princess Street Gallery. Later, check out the dance clubs in Harbour Town. There are lots of exciting spots on Dunmore and Bay Street. Copyright © Luxury Retreats. All rights reserved. BEDROOM & BATHROOM • Bedroom 1 - Primary: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with hallway access, Stand-alone shower & bathtub, Dual vanity, Walk-in closet, Safe, Direct access to balcony • Bedroom 2: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Safe, Ceiling fan • Bedroom 3: 2 Twin size beds, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Walk-in closet, Direct access to balcony • Bedroom 4: 2 Twin size beds, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Ceiling fan • Bedroom 5: Queen size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Walk-in closet, Ceiling fan FEATURES & AMENITIES • More under “What this place offers” below Included: • Housekeeping - 6 hrs per day • More under “What this place offers” below Extra Cost (advance notice may be required): • Activities and excursions • More under “Add-on services” below

Kings Surf Shack

Indulge in the coveted bohemian lifestyle the Bahamas is known for at this Dunmore Town villa. Its reclaimed barn exterior exudes a charmingly vintage feel, complete with a remodeled 1984 VW food truck in the backyard. A spacious pool provides instant relief from the balmy afternoon heat. Stargaze with a glass of champagne in the bubbling hot tub. Sought-after Pink Sands Beach is mere steps away. Copyright © Luxury Retreats. All rights reserved. BEDROOM & BATHROOM • Bedroom 1 - Primary: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower & bathtub, Alfresco shower, Walk-in closet • Bedroom 2: Queen size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower • Bedroom 3: Children Room: 2 Twin over double size bunk beds, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower Guest House • Bedroom 4: 2 Twin size beds over King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Television • Bedroom 5: King size bed, Ensuite bathroom with stand-alone shower, Fully equipped kitchen, Television STAFF & SERVICES Extra Cost (advance notice may be required): • Activities and excursions • More under “Add-on services” below

Bali House Harbour Island - Private Pool, Gym, Bea

Unwind at Bali House Bahamas, your exclusive 7,200 sq ft haven on Harbour Island, where the soft pink sands are just a few steps away. This magnificent villa, originally built in 2020 and meticulously reimagined in 2025 by its new owners, presents six sprawling bedrooms designed for ultimate comfort and style. Indulge in a seamless, five-star experience with our dedicated manager, complimentary concierge, two housekeepers, private gym, and daily beach setup. From sun-drenched afternoons to livel

At Ease Harbour Island - Pool, Staff, Beach Cabana

Luxury awaits at At Ease, a 5-star Harbour Island villa steps from the world-famous Pink Sand Beach. This designer-owned retreat, featured in HGTV and Coastal Living, boasts a private pool, outdoor bar, and included concierge service. Enjoy daily housekeeping, chef options, and golf cart rentals for exploring Dunmore Town. Everything from VIP airport transfers to curated excursions, we create a seamless and unforgettable Bahamas vacation. A perfect Harbour Island escape awaits At Ease!

Villa in Royal Island

Private Island All Inclusive

Royal Island is a completely private 430-acre oasis with five intimate bungalows on the sand and three additional suites, surrounded by miles of untouched turquoise sea. Awarded one of the top resorts in the world by Condé Nast Traveller, Royal Island combines personalized luxury and island adventure in an exclusively private setting for up to 18 guests. For families who want to celebrate, connect in a new way, and jump into a curated Bahamian Experience. Water Sports Private Beach

A space that's all yours, with room for everyone

Three Bees Estate Beachfront Gem

Discover Three Bees, a luxurious 13-bedroom estate on Harbour Island, Bahamas. This exclusive retreat offers access to the famed Pink Sand Beach and a private bayside beach for ultimate seaside luxury. Enjoy resort-quality water toys and boats for endless ocean adventures. Just a 5-minute golf cart ride from historic Dunmore Town, Three Bees is the perfect getaway for families and groups seeking both relaxation and adventure.

Holiday rentals for every style

Get the amount of space that is right for you

Houses

Villas

Luxurious estates for the ultimate escape

Bungalows

Intimate homes, inviting architecture

Popular amenities for Eleuthera luxury holiday rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great luxury holiday rentals in Eleuthera

Villa in Governor's Harbour

5 out of 5 average rating, 9 reviews

Snaresbrook Manor

Home in North Eleuthra

Middle Cay

Pink Sands Resort 2 Bed with Pool

Three Bees Estate Beachfront Gem

Bali House Harbour Island - Private Pool, Gym, Bea

Banyan Tree

At Ease Harbour Island - Pool, Staff, Beach Cabana