Bar

Island Burgers & Shakes

27 locals recommend,

Tips from locals

Joshua
March 30, 2016
Burgers, burgers, BURGERS!!! Island Burger doesn’t have fries on their menu; instead they’ve got the thickest shakes and best selection of specialty burgers that you can find. I have quite the fondness for their Chile Burger—a diner classic, yes, but not when cooked medium rare and paired with sourdough bread and basil-infused chili. My brother ordered the Cowboy Burger, an all-beef patty smothered in BBQ sauce, ranch dressing, and Monterey Jack cheese. For the faint of heart, grilled chicken can be substituted.
Burgers, burgers, BURGERS!!! Island Burger doesn’t have fries on their menu; instead they’ve got the thickest shakes and best selection of specialty burgers that you can find. I have quite the fondness for their Chile Burger—a diner classic, yes, but not when cooked medium rare and paired with sourd…
Ms.
December 8, 2015
Cuisines: American , Really good Burgers . Price: $20
Philip & Georgina
May 29, 2012
Recommended by New York Magazine, California flavors and theme.
Patricia
January 8, 2017
huge burgers and live jazz
Jay
June 21, 2015
More types of burgers than you've seen on any other menu, great place.

Unique things to do nearby

DUMBO/Brooklyn Bridge photo walk
The Full-Day "See It All" NYC Tour!
Speakeasy and secret bar tour

Locals also recommend