Boutique hotels in Lake Montauk

Find and book unique boutique hotels on Airbnb

Top-rated boutique hotels in Lake Montauk

Guests agree: these boutique hotels are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Superhost
A spacious bedroom features a four-poster bed with a light-colored blanket and decorative pillows. Two windows dressed in soft blue curtains enhance natural light. An accent bench at the foot of the bed is paired with bedside lamps and dark wood furniture, creating a serene environment.
Hotel room in Old Lyme

Spectacular 2 Bath King Suite in Historic Mansion

Enjoy a luxurious experience when you stay in the Master Suite at Ludington House. Ascend the Grand Staircase to the second floor to find the showpiece of the nine bedroom mansion. The private suite features His and Hers Bathrooms/Dressing Room and a four post King Bed. Outside your suite you have use of the "morning room"; a charming light-filled living area filled with local art and literature that is shared with one other guestroom. The adjoining foyer has a small kitchenette for beverages.

Superhost
The welcoming lobby features elegant arched doorways and a chandelier hanging from the high ceiling. A decorative area rug is positioned in the center, complementing the hardwood flooring. A staircase with a red carpet leads to the upper level, while large windows allow natural light to shine in.
Hotel room in Middletown
4.65 out of 5 average rating, 77 reviews

Carriage House Newport 2 Double Beds (breakfast)

The charming Carriage House is the perfect place to spend your Newport visit. Centrally located and a Victorian décor gives you an authentic Newport experience. COMPLIMENTARY breakfast as well. Guests can use the amenities at our sister property, The Atlantic Beach Hotel, which include indoor pool, seasonal rooftop sundeck, gym, and guest laundry. Check out Tickets Bar & Grille - just 1 mile away. Enroll in their loyalty for an instant free reward! Must be 21+ to check in. Not pet-friendly.

Guest favourite
Hotel room in mystic
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Pet Friendly King Suite 3 Min Walk Downtown Mystic

Located in the heart of downtown Mystic’s Historic District, this charming 600 sq ft suite offers a relaxing coastal stay just a 3 min walk from shops, restaurants, marinas, and the waterfront. The suite includes a king bed, pull out futon, propane fireplace, kitchenette, private bath, AC, Smart TV, WiFi, and off street parking. Behind the Carriage House, enjoy a beautiful brick patio with English gardens, outdoor seating, charcoal grill, hammock, and fire pit, just minutes from Mystic Seaport.

Guest favourite
A well-lit room features two queen beds with decorative pillows, flanked by wooden headboards. Light red curtains frame a window, and art pieces hang on the cream-colored walls. A small air conditioning unit is visible near the window, and the floor is covered with a deep red carpet.
Hotel room in Newport
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

2 Queen Beds - America's Cup Inn

2 Queen Bedroom with private bathroom overlooking Thames St. This is a very charming room in the heart of Newport Downtown. You'll be a few steps from pubs like Brick Alley Pub & right across the street from Irish Pub, few steps from restaurants like The Mooring, The Black Pear, 22 Bowen's and more, you choose! Close to bars, arcade, ice cream & the Newport Shipyard. Walk 2 minutes and you'll be at the Perrotti Park waiting for the ferry tours around the Island. Second floor room, no elevator.

Superhost
A spacious guest room features hardwood flooring and a comfortable bed with neutral bedding. The room includes a wooden nightstand and a lamp, while a large mirror and a television are positioned on the wall. A small desk area and closet add functionality to the space.
Hotel room in Southampton
4.76 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Somewhere in the Hamptons

Southampton LI Hotel - Your Next Vacation Destination. Conveniently located, only minutes from the world's famous Cooper's Beach and charming Village of Southampton with numerous restaurants, cafes and boutiques - Southampton Long Island Hotel will be your favorite lodging choice in the Hamptons. Open all year long - it is perfect for the summer beach getaway, business retreat, relaxing tour of exceptional wineries or just for a well deserved relaxing weekend as a treat for yourself.

Guest favourite
Hotel room in Groton
5 out of 5 average rating, 5 reviews

Mariner's Suite #103 at the Mystic River Inn

Barrier-Free Luxury · Direct Downtown Access · Sleeps up to 4 Where Historic Charm Meets Modern Indulgence. Thoughtfully designed with Universal Access in mind, this pet-friendly ground-floor suite offers a spacious, barrier-free layout without compromising on historic charm. The expansive living lounge provides generous room to unwind and includes comfortable seating that converts into a premium full-size sleeper sofa, allowing the suite to easily accommodate up to four guests.

Top guest favourite
A well-lit hallway is showcased, featuring a blend of hardwood flooring and elegant wall sconces. Framed artwork adorns the walls, while a console table stands against one side. An archway leads to a living area, where a fireplace can be seen in the background.
Hotel room in Newport
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 927 reviews

Boutique Hotel Suite in Downtown Newport

Spacious boutique suite in downtown Newport with full kitchen, parking & fireplaces or balconies in select units. Stay in the heart of downtown Newport — steps from the harbor, historic mansions, and lively Thames Street. Your spacious one-bedroom suite at Pelham Court Hotel offers the perfect balance of home comfort and boutique style, with a full kitchen, on-site parking, and complimentary Wi-Fi.

Hotel room in Montauk
New place to stay

Montauk Soundview Cottage 2

Welcome to Cottage 2 at the Montauk Soundview! Enjoy our 2 bedroom 1 bath cottage equipped with a Queen Size bed, 2 Twin beds, and a sleeper sofa. We are walking distance to the Montauk Harbor and the neighboring restaurants. Enjoy the breathtaking sunsets from our sand deck area. Do not miss the opportunity to have an excellent stay on the Block Island Sound.

Guest favourite
A cozy bedroom features a spacious bed adorned with decorative pillows and a soft blanket. Skylights allow natural light to fill the room. A television is positioned across from the bed, and a green plant adds a touch of decor to the space.
Hotel room in Narragansett
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 134 reviews

Cozy Hotel, Room #1

Our premier room, located on the third floor, offers the ultimate in comfort and vintage style. It features a luxurious king bed and a spacious bathroom with a large, tiled shower. A cozy couch and a record player invite you to relax and unwind in this serene retreat. *This unit is on the 3rd floor. There is no elevator.*

Guest favourite
The image captures a serene view of a sandy beach meeting the ocean, with soft waves gently lapping at the shore. A wooden barrier is visible, suggesting separation between the beach and the grassy area behind it. The sky is clear and blue, enhancing the tranquil atmosphere.
Hotel room in Montauk
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Montauk OceanEnd 5

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. This dreamy oceanfront 1 bdrm apt was recently renovated with gorgeous furnishings, no expense spared. Steps to the sand and a few blocks to the heart of town. This unique place will make you feel like you’re in another realm. Come and grab your slice of heaven!

A spacious bedroom features a light blue quilt covering a comfortable bed with two decorative pillows. A nightstand with a lamp illuminates the space, while natural light enters through the nearby window, complemented by a partially opened curtain.
Hotel room in Montauk
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Sun 'N' Sound, Bayfront Studio Lower

Exclusive waterfront resorts make any vacation memorable, especially at a place like Sun N’ Sound. The hotel tops hospitality expectations by all measures. The large accommodations are designed for comfortable long term stays. You’ll feel right at home during your time in our comfy guest rooms.

Top guest favourite
A modern bedroom features a spacious bed with a white quilt and blue accents. A large television is mounted on the wall, while a window allows natural light to fill the room. A dresser offers additional storage, complementing the overall clean decor.
Hotel room in Stonington
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 31 reviews

Cove Ledge Marina Room 2D on Water w/ Pool & Kayak

Located at Cove Ledge Marina, this newly renovated one-room unit is just steps away from the tranquil waters of the marina and includes complimentary access to the outdoor pool and recreation areas, as well as a complimentary Kayak rental.

Popular amenities for Lake Montauk boutique hotels

Destinations to explore

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. New York
  4. Suffolk County
  5. Montauk
  6. Lake Montauk
  7. Boutique hotels