Holiday rentals in Tarpum Bay

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

0 of 0 items showing
1 of 3 pages

Popular amenities for Tarpum Bay holiday rentals

Other great holiday rentals in Tarpum Bay

Guest favourite
Home in North Palmetto Point
5 out of 5 average rating, 6 reviews

Dance your way to Mango Tango

LauraRating, 5 stars3 weeks ago
Great place, very clean and new, near several restaurants and beaches. Melisa was a great host, kept us informed and replied promptly. Very cute and peaceful place.
Home in Winding Bay
5 out of 5 average rating, 3 reviews

Wonderful Winding Bay

MargaretRating, 5 stars3 months ago
The pictures don't do justice to this home (light and beautiful) and its surroundings (paradise). There should be one of the view from the deck directly down to the ocean! :) Architecture is stunning. Full on views of the beach and tropical vegetation from every side. Two different work spaces with desks and views out the back. Kitchen is a little small if you're having a big group, but for two it was terrific. Everything worked. Fans in all the rooms! Great shower with fabulous water pressure. Loved the simplicity of the decor and having the beach to ourselves. BE SURE TO READ THE INSTRUCTIONS (and maybe print them at home). VERY useful information. Contact Latoya for practical questions. She was able to get us a rental car when other companies said they had no vehicles left. Do get a 4WD. The high chassis is important for rutted roads if you go anywhere off the beaten track. We didn't plan to, but it happens! :)
Guest favourite
Flat in Savannah Sound
4.8 out of 5 average rating, 25 reviews

Tranquility Suites #2

AnaRating, 5 stars5 months ago
Tranquility was a home away from home. The only concern was the internet was in and out on the island, something beyond anyone control. But the place was beautiful and clean. Thanks again for your hospitality.
Home in Tarpum Bay
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 58 reviews

"Baha Mara" Tarpum Bay

JcRating, 5 stars2 months ago
We really enjoyed our stay at Baha Mara. It was everything we had hoped for and more. The house itself is spacious and light-filled, well appointed and equipped, with lovely art and nice touches throughout. Comfortable beds and living room space, great kitchen for cooking, large porch for sitting out. We spent a lot of time relaxing on the day beds at water's edge, as well as exploring the tide line and in the water on the SUPs and with snorkels. This was our first visit to Eleuthera, and we found Baha Mara to be perfectly located to venture out to various villages, beaches, restaurants and grocery options not too far from the house. We discovered on our first day that the closest eastside beach, Islandia, is closed to the public pending a sale of the surrounding 466+ acres (!), so we explored a handful of the myriad sandy stretches up and down the coast. We only wished that we had more days to spend and that we had booked a day out on the boat with John/Big Mac Fishing. Next time!
Cottage in Tarpum Bay
4.58 out of 5 average rating, 24 reviews

Sea view - 2 Bedroom Cottage

Maticia Rating, 5 stars6 months ago
Donna was a great host. She is super friendly, professional and responsive. This property is great to experience living like a local. I will return soon
Flat in Tarpum Bay
4.5 out of 5 average rating, 8 reviews

Bayside Beach Rentals - Unit #1

MarioRating, 5 stars11 months ago
Comfortable stay. Convenient location. Highly recommend.
Home in Tarpum Bay
4.75 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Flanders Cottage

DonRating, 5 stars10 months ago
Great spot. Jonathan was always prompt when responding to a question both before and during our stay. Great local knowledge. Thank you!!
Home in Eleuthera
5 out of 5 average rating, 4 reviews

Watercolor Bay @ Tarpum Bay

JordanRating, 5 stars2 months ago
We stayed April 5-19 2025. The house is new, spacious and great window light coming in. Comfortable bedding etc. the house is on kind of a rocky beach but it is one of the few we have found on Eleuthera with shells! The back porch facing the ocean was one of our favorites spots to hang out when not in the sun. There are 2 hammocks in the yard which were so relaxing. Ken, brother in law of owner lives close by and checked in with us and as the house is new and just started being rented out he said to let him know if we think of anything it might need. We travel to Eleuthera about once a year. And there were a couple itemsI I thought the place could use and presto! Ken had them to us by evening! That was fantastic so now there is a cooler to use, some additional kitchen items and an iron 🙂 David also checked in when we arrived and after we checked out. We really like Neek’s. Eats for food and drinks and it is only about 5 min. Away. There are some games there and we left a couple book

Destinations to explore