Private suite holiday rentals in Cayuga Lake

The Lakeview Nook – Midcentury Modern Stay

Enjoy this mid-century modern guest house in a spectacular site, with a lake view, waterfall, and forest all in one place. The house was just fully renovated. This house is just 2 miles from Ithaca downtown and 3 miles from Cornell University. The location is super close to everything Ithaca has to offer—Ithaca falls, downtown, restaurants, the farmer's market, wineries, all within a few minutes drive of your rental. This unit is fully private, with no shared areas/entrance with the other unit.

Family · Location · Beach

The Guest Suite at Walnut Grove Farmhouse

This wing of my renovated and restored 1880’s farmhouse has private front and back entrances leading to the main hallway/parlor. Living room with TV, puzzles, games, cards, magazines, and more. The adjoining kitchen and dining area offers many amenities such as fridge, stove, microwave, coffee service. Under stairs is a half bath. Up the grand staircase are two large queen rooms with full bathrooms en suite, as well as an additional queen bedroom w/out bath. Tasteful, comfortable, thoughtful.

Location · Family · Hospitality

Overlooking beautiful Keuka: Sunrise to Sunset!

A self-contained apt right in the heart of the beautiful Finger Lakes. Close to Keuka College, parks, restaurants, museums, trails, wineries, and kayak/bike rentals. Room for boats/trailers. Self-check in with lock box Super clean, lower apartment features a private entrance. It has a large bedroom with a comfortable king size bed, convertible to two twins, upon request. Twin/mattresses on floor can sleep up to 2 children ($15 ea) or 1 more adult($40)per night Private bathroom with shower.

Value · Family · Getting around

Tranquil Ithaca Stay

Experience tranquility and convenience in our cozy apartment nestled in the heart of Ithaca. Stay refreshed as you enjoy the perfect blend of serenity and easy access to your destinations. Within a five-minute drive, you'll reach Cornell University, the Ithaca Airport, the Cornell Lab of Ornithology, shopping areas, and bus routes to other attractions. Revel in the comfort of a new queen-sized bed, sofa bed, a spacious living room, a well-equipped kitchen, and a private patio in the backyard.

Location · Value · Parking

The Taughannock Falls Suite

A peaceful Finger Lakes retreat tucked between Ithaca and Trumansburg, just minutes from Taughannock Falls and Cayuga Lake. Set on five scenic acres with direct access to the Black Diamond Trail, our private two-bedroom guest suite is designed for slow mornings, outdoor adventures, and cozy nights in. Whether you’re here to explore natural beauty, visit campus, enjoy wine country, or simply unwind, this is an easy place to relax. Bring your bikes, bring your pup, and make yourself at home.

Value · Family · Back garden

Charming Farmhouse Suite | Vineyard & Lake Views

Experience one of the Finger Lakes' most beautiful vineyard settings. Our private guest suite is tucked into a working vineyard farm with expansive lawns, breathtaking Seneca Lake views, and plenty of space to relax, enjoy a glass of wine, play lawn games, or take in the sunset. Attached to our home with its own private entrance, this ground level suite features modern farmhouse style, luxury linens, and a kitchenette—all just minutes from the region's best food, wineries and Watkins Glen.

Family · Value · Hot tub

Peaceful Finger Lakes Retreat

Escape to the Finger Lakes! Centrally located apartment for visiting wine country (right between Cayuga and Seneca Lake wine trails) and just 3 miles from Taughannock Falls State Park. 2 miles into charming downtown Trumansburg for gourmet dining and small town charm. 20 minutes by car will get you to- Downtown Ithaca, Downtown Watkins Glen, and so much more. Visit Cornell or IC but enjoy the countryside. Escape from the city while still enjoying fine dining, wine tasting, and night life!

Location · Value · Long stay

Finger Lakes Wine Country Suite

Beautifully restored 1875 village home 2 blocks from Seneca Lake, in the heart of wine country. Our quaint village is centrally located on Seneca Lake where over 50 wineries/breweries await you. Keuka outlet trail is a few blocks away- use our bikes to explore gorgeous waterfalls and trails. Your spacious private suite has a separate entrance and porch all to yourself with mini frig,microwave and Keurig. along with an en suite bathroom. The Copper Barn next door has additional lodging.

Location · Family · Quiet

Finger Lakes themed Cottage at New Park - Artistic

Key-hole shaped bathroom door, elephant themed mosaic made from Seneca Lake fossils, a tiled map of the Finger Lakes region in the shower, stone surrounded mirror, and a Finger Lakes shaped bar sink are only a few of the superfluous, yet beguiling details that line the Finger Lakes Cottage. It has incredible hardwood trim, granite countertops, and stained glass rescued from an old NYC church. Furthermore, it sleeps up to 4 people (queen+double) and is incredibly dog-friendly.

Location · Family · Nearby

The 1113 Hideaway

If you are looking for a hidden gem while visiting the Ithaca area you need not look any further. This is a newly built 2 bedroom apt, with a fully equipped kitchen and full size washer/dryer. We put a lot of thought into the detail when building/decorating this apartment...we want our guest to feel at home while staying here. Sit on the deck and watch the birds while enjoying your favorite beverage. While visiting check out the many gorges, falls, and wineries.

Location · Value · Decor

Modern ‘Barn-dominium’ in the Village

A short walk to the charming village of Trumansburg, NY, this studio-like guest suite is perfectly situated near lakeside wineries, beautiful Taughannock Falls, numerous hiking trails, Cornell University and Ithaca College. The Barndominium provides an opportunity for a lovely country getaway, with modern amenities (including free wi-fi) within reach – restaurants, bars, shops, coffee, ice-cream and a full-service grocery store are all nearby.

Location · Family · Walkability

Guest Suite at Chauncey House

Join us for a stay in our historically grand 1835 home, perfectly located in the heart of Downtown Ithaca. Everything you’re looking for is only a few walkable blocks away: Moosewood & shopping at Dewitt Mall – 1 block. Shopping & Events in Ithaca Commons – 2 blocks. Restaurant Row on Aurora Street – 3 blocks. Ithaca Farmers Market – 1 mile. If you're visiting students, Cornell University and Ithaca College are both nearby.

Family · Value · Sleep quality