Cabin holiday rentals in Green Lake County

We had a wonderful stay at Cherie’s place! We were really looking forward to a nice quiet / private stay and it did not disappoint! We loved feeding the goats, taking the canoe out on the river, walking around in the woods, and of course chilling in the hot tub. Everything was very high quality, clean, and easy to use. We would def recommend this place and we will be coming back again in the future! 10/10!

We had a great visit! We loved all the amenities (kayaks, hot tub, outdoor patio) for our girls weekend. Thank you!

We had the absolute best time. This was by far the most thoughtfully stocked house we’ve ever rented. It was great!

This cabin was perfect for a getaway with my husband. We loved the private location nestled in the woods. The hot tub was great. We also really appreciated the recommendations about a few easy local hikes and sites to see in Montello that made for a fun morning adventure. Everything was as pictured online. The only downside was some lackluster water pressure in the shower, but that was a very minor negative. In the grand scheme of things, this place was a gem!

My family and I had a wonderful few days at Bonnie’s place. It had outstanding amenities - a nice hot tub, well supplied kitchen, and all the boats you could want when staying on a beautiful lake. We’d definitely recommend it to others.

Absolutely wonderful! It was an amazing place for our annual Mother/Daughter weekend! Looking forward to next year! 🥰

Great place to stay, very responsive, easy instructions and house rules. Thank you Emily for allowing us in your home

Peaceful location with lots to do. Bonnie was very attentive.

Beautiful cabin - peaceful and private. Our dog lived his best life running around the yard and my 7 year old loved the swing set and our kayak rides. The cabin was spotless when we arrived and everything was comfortable and well-stocked.

We had a last-minute change in our travel plans and still wanted to make the most of our vacation. Luckily, my husband found the Blackberry Lodge—and what an amazing find it was! We’re so happy we chose to stay here. From the start, Andrew (the owner and Super Host) was incredibly responsive, thoughtful, and understanding about our situation. He made everything so easy, even on short notice. The lodge itself had everything we needed to feel completely at home—cozy, well-equipped, and full of charm. We truly enjoyed every moment and are already looking forward to coming back to create even more wonderful memories. Highly recommend this place and host. Thank you, Andrew!

Place was as described, and somehow still better. Trevor was cool, animals were cool, cabin was everything we thought it would be, bigger than expected. You have your pick to what you want to do. Kayak, use it! Canoe, go for it! Want to feed the goats, here’s where the food is! All the luxuries of owning your own farm, but someone else has all the responsibilities. This was our first farm stay, and probably one of if not the best Airbnb’s we stayed at. Less than ten minutes to downtown, but when you’re at the cabin, there is an abundance of wildlife. Want to talk to Trevor? Go for it. Want to be left alone? That’s cool too. I can’t say enough about this place. Not a single complaint. Thanks again for everything Trevor, the eggs on the way out were icing on the cake. Stay here, you won’t regret it!

This is our 4th time visiting this cabin and it never disappoints! The last time my now husband and I were here was a few years ago when we got engaged at the park down the road. We love sitting by the fire, fishing by the pier and cooking yummy meals. We always leave feeling relaxed and rejuvenated.

wonderful cabin and location at a great price, just book it!

We absolutely LOVED our stay at Barbara’s cabin! It was MAGICAL! The property was completely private and peaceful. The most private and peaceful property we have ever visited. The fact that it is located in an area with many Amish neighbors means that there is a peace and quiet as well as harmony in the countryside. We would sit out for our morning coffee on the porch swing and listen to the passing of the horses and carriages. We sat outside all day long every day soaking in the peaceful serenity and the glorious old woods that surrounded us. The best of which was the stunning huge old Oak Tree that graces the front yard. In the morning we would hear the birdsong and the wind in the trees. At nighttime it would grow quiet and last night I heard a Whip-Poor-Will for the first time in my life! Amazing! We bought organic fruit and vegetables at the nearby Amish roadside stand, Busy Bees. The cabin was comfy, cozy& amazingly clean! The windows were spotless! A gem!

We had a lovely stay in Montello. The cabin was perfect for a weekend getaway for two couples—clean, cozy, and well-stocked. We really enjoyed cooking meals in the kitchen and spending our evenings around the fire pit. The yard is spacious and we loved sitting outside in the evenings to relax. One note is that the cabin is next to a semi-busy main road which we didn’t realize. It wasn’t too bad but not as secluded as we had hoped. Other than that it was the perfect spot to unwind and enjoy nature. Highly recommend!

This cabin was so cute and cozy. I saw reviews saying how it’s more beautiful in person and I agree! Loved the spacious backyard. We brought our dog and he loved running around there. We walked the trails in the back and it was a great vibe. The kitchen had all the utensils we needed, we loved the games downstairs as well as the cozy upstairs while watching movies. This cabin feels private so it’s a great getaway. We loved being outside most of the time just grilling and enjoying the sound of nature. I def recommend this cabin. Noemi was also very responsive when I needed her which I appreciate.

Had a great stay, I would definitely recommend! Tacara replied within minutes if we had any questions and the place felt like home as soon as we arrived. (Since it is near the lake there are a lot of mosquitos at night).

Great cabin for a getaway from the city. Anthony was very kind and helpful, especially with plowing the driveway after a large snowfall.

The cabin was beautiful and perfectly curated! We loved our stay here. Katherine was very kind, communicative, and responsive.

Great Spot Near Green Lake The Salty Dog Lodge was the perfect base for our golf weekend. Clean, comfortable, and well-equipped-everything we needed. The outdoor space was solid for hanging out. Easy drive to Green Lake. Host was on point, no issues at all. Would definitely come back.

Clean, simple and easy. Great location if you’re looking to take advantage of the lake that’s a short walk away.

Super cozy cabin, great location between Princeton and Green Lake. Host was very responsive. Cabin was very clean, and had everything you would need.

This cabin was perfect for a cozy little weekend getaway with my husband and my dog. The cabin is very well stocked with all necessities you may need. We appreciated having things like seasonings & aluminum foil for cooking, and Tupperware for leftovers. This is one of the most dog friendly rentals we’ve been to. They had a pop up dog crate, a dog bed, dog toys, and water/food bowls. We enjoyed taking the kayaks out on the lake and playing some yard games. In regards to the location it is on a dead end street so traffic was minimal other than the neighbors driving by. It was a very quick drive into town to buy groceries. When we arrived we couldn’t find the Roku and Emily was quick to respond to our messages. A prior guest must have stolen it, but she sent someone out the next day to set up a new device which was greatly appreciated as we were stuck inside the next night due to rain. We got our security deposit hold reversed within 2 days. We would definitely recommend this cabin.

We loved staying here! So much to do and we didn’t even have to leave the house!