Holiday rentals in Shelter Island

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 91 reviews

Surf Scoter Cottage Shelter Island

New heated gunnite Pool & pea gravel driveway. 4BR renovated mid-century ranch with a breezy nautical theme. Central A/C. Giant back deck: Propane & Charcoal BBQ, Jacuzzi, Hammock & glorious Outdoor Shower. Private front & back yards. Fab mirrored bar, cozy kitchen, double-sink master bath+full 2nd bath. Impressive vinyl collect & 4 speaker Bluetooth stereo, Piano, chill basement media room + ping pong & foosball ! washer/dryer. 4 bikes, beach chairs, cooler & umbrella. $100 /dog sorry no cats

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 47 reviews

Home in Sag Harbor

Luxe NEW Beach Cottage-Steps to Water-Firepit

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish beach cottage with NEW Kitchen and NEW bathroom (completed April 2026) in Sag Harbor. It is the perfect spot for a single or couple to enjoy the Hamptons beachy lifestyle. Fully appointed for your stay, just bring your bathing suit. Outside is your own patio with sitting area, dining table with umbrella, BBQ and my own tiny cottage “Bouy Cottage” is across the lawn so I (or other guests may be there in May-Sept. Beach chairs, umbrella and smiles!

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

A serene beach scene captures a golden sunset reflecting on calm waters. The sandy shore leads to gentle ripples, while distant land silhouettes frame the horizon. A tranquil ambiance is created as the sun descends, providing a peaceful setting for evening strolls.

Flat in Southold

Bright, Southold Studio Apt near beach & town

Pied a terre on the North Fork, in the heart of Southold village. Gorgeous bay beach 5 minute walk, as are farmstands, supermarket, Historic Southold Village with quaint shops, Hampton Jitney & LIRR. Lots of light, new contemporary space featuring full bathroom with bathtub. Perfect for one, suitable for a couple for weekend getaway. Small kitchenette perfect for simple food prep, morning coffee/tea. Chickens on property, fresh pastured eggs in your kitchenette upon arrival!

An expansive outdoor area features a heated pool and hot tub, surrounded by lush greenery and tall trees. Lounge chairs with umbrellas are positioned nearby, set against a backdrop of vibrant grass and shaded by mature trees, creating a serene space for relaxation.

4.91 out of 5 average rating, 33 reviews

Newly Renovated w/ Pool, Hot tub & Fireplace

Shelter Island Rental License #: 2025-L-0056 !!!PLEASE DO NOT PUT IN A BOOKING REQUEST UNTIL WE HAVE HAD A CONVERSATION VIA THIS SITE. THANK YOU!!!! Great for fall and winter! Perfect for families! 4 Adults Max. Newly renovated, light filled home! Heated pool and hot tub in summer in a private tree-filled yard. Fireplace and great sledding in the colder months. Mid-century modern style; close to Shelter Island Heights and beaches. **POOL & HOT TUB CLOSED MID OCTOBER UNTIL MAY**

Guest suite in North Fork

A serene beach scene is depicted, showcasing soft white sand bordered by gentle waves. Tall grasses sway in the foreground, framing the clear blue water that extends to the horizon, providing a sense of calm and natural beauty.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Enjoy a relaxing getaway to the North Fork

One bedroom suite, with separate entrance in quiet Nassau Point; a peninsula, surrounded by beaches. Nassau Point is a great place to bike, walk and enjoy nature. Fully functioning WiFI for guests looking to extend their stay, while working from home. Fishermen's beach is a 5 minute walk Causeway beach is a 10 minute walk with parking. Point beach, 1.5 mile walk, a Southold Parking Permit required. You will find 20 wineries within 5 miles, just a short Uber ride away.

Cottage in Shelter Island

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 50 reviews

Cozy Shelter Island 2 Bedroom 1 Bath Cottage

This cozy cottage is perfect place to relax and unwind. Located in the center of the island about a mile from the beach and nature preserve. Sleeps up to 9 people - with queen size aero bed provided. Linens, dishes, utensils etc. included. Fridge has icemaker and filtered water feature. Outdoor covered dining area with table and 8 chairs. 2 person swing, BBQ & outdoor shower. 2/3 acre property. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay.

The living area features warm wood paneling and ample natural light from large windows. A wood-burning stove is positioned beside a comfortable sofa, with a chandelier offering soft illumination. A coffee table sits centrally, with various seating options and artwork on display.

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 172 reviews

Shelter island retreat

Private Top-Floor Retreat on Shelter IslandPrivate two-bedroom top-floor apartment on a secluded one-acre property on Shelter Island. Features a wood-burning fireplace, stainless steel kitchen, layered decks, private hot tub, outdoor sauna, and fire pit. Just a five-minute walk to the beach and close to the South Ferry. Private entrance and peaceful wooded setting. Guests enjoy exclusive use of the hot tub, sauna, and fire pit. Long-term rentals available.

A spacious house is framed by lush landscaping, featuring a large pool in the foreground. Sun loungers and patio umbrellas are arranged around the pool, along with a pink float. The exterior showcases a combination of shingle siding and solar panels under a clear blue sky.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 72 reviews

Beautiful beach home with pool & water views!

Perfectly situated just past the Island Boatyard and Salt in a blissful neighborhood surrounded by water on 3 sides. 4 town landings and beach access right across the street. Newly renovated gourmet kitchen with large island and beautiful quartz counters. Back deck offers full outdoor dining space with propane Weber grill, wicker seating area with beautiful propane Firepit for hours of evening enjoyment and chaise lounges by the pool.

Guest house in Shelter Island Heights

A serene saltwater pool is framed by lush greenery and blooming flowers, enhancing the outdoor space. A hot tub is positioned alongside, inviting relaxation. The guest house is visible in the background, surrounded by trees and well-maintained landscaping.

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 73 reviews

Bayfront 1BR/2BR detached guesthouse with pool

Perfect relaxing getaway for a couple or family. Bayfront 1BR/2BR fully detached guest house with gorgeous morning views. Property has saltwater pool + hot tub (open May -October) and bay access via private dock. Central to both north & south forks (wineries + Hamptons or Montauk just short drive away). Down the road from famous Shelter Island Sunset Beach + golf course. Come explore the beauty of the Hamptons without the stress!

The exterior of a two-story house is depicted, featuring a light-colored facade with a welcoming front porch. Clear blue skies and greenery surround the property, while the lawn is well-maintained, offering a spacious area in front of the house.

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Hamptons - Shelter Island Farmhouse

Kid friendly! Perfect two family split! Come enjoy our island retreat. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful pad. You will be 2 min on bike from Wades Beach. You can also walk to the best BBQ/seafood in Shelter, Commander Codys. Features a large open kitchen/dining room plus also a spacious living room. 4 bedrooms with new mattresses, huge outdoor patio for family BBQs. No dogs please.

A modern mid-century ranch house is set against a clear blue sky. Lush green grass surrounds the home, complemented by neatly trimmed shrubs. A paved pathway leads to the entrance, while trees provide a natural backdrop, enhancing the privacy of the property.

4.9 out of 5 average rating, 51 reviews

Silver Beach, 3 Bedroom cottage w/ pool

Enjoy summer on Shelter Island in this 3 bedroom, 2 bathroom, freshly painted and well equipped MCM ranch house on 3/4 of an acre. Located at the end of a private road, it's in walking distance to Shell Beach, town landings and a beautiful sunset viewing spot. Brand new, heated, inground pool w/ color changing light, central air, deck, fire pit and BBQ make this a great vacation home.

A spacious living area features a brick fireplace with a mounted television above. Light-colored sofas are arranged around a wooden coffee table. Natural light enters through large windows, with a dining area visible in the background. Decorative lanterns adorn a rustic table.

5 out of 5 average rating, 20 reviews

Laid Back Relaxation

Kick back and relax in this calm, stylish space. Nice newly updated home on a quiet street within walking distance to beaches, restaurants and a golf course. Great location near Shelter Island heights town, Crescent beach and Sunset beach. The location provides both privacy and relaxation at home with just a short walk or ride to popular Shelter Island spots.

Popular amenities for Shelter Island holiday rentals

Kitchen

Wifi

Pool

Free parking on premises

Air conditioning

Other great holiday rentals in Shelter Island

Cottage in Shelter Island Heights

A bright living area features large windows that overlook a serene waterfront. Two modern white sofas are positioned around a glass coffee table, with a small lamp on each side. A wood-burning fireplace and built-in shelving add to the contemporary design.

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 27 reviews

Waterfront Getaway on Shelter Island

4.93 out of 5 average rating, 83 reviews

Family Friendly Island Home

A spacious wooden deck is featured, equipped with a dining table and lounge chairs. The entrance to the house is visible, illuminated by soft outdoor lights. Surrounding greenery adds a natural element, creating a welcoming outdoor space for relaxation.

Bungalow in Shelter Island Heights

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 16 reviews

Two bedroom bungalow

Guest house in Shelter Island Heights

A spacious studio features a cozy queen bed with a light grey duvet and matching pillows, complemented by two ceiling fans. A comfortable seating arrangement includes a modern sofa and armchair. Large windows provide ample natural light, and a soft area rug enhances the warm aesthetic.

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Stylish Studio Suite on Shelter Island

5 out of 5 average rating, 23 reviews

Shelter Island Retreat, 5 bdrms near everything!

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 12 reviews

Captain Don’s Paradise

Flat in Shelter Island Heights

The living area features large glass doors that open to a view of trees and distant water. A light grey rug anchors two chairs and a sectional sofa, while a small circular coffee table holds a chess set. A television is mounted on the wall.

5 out of 5 average rating, 17 reviews

Modern Waterview Apartment in Silver Beach

A charming single-story house is set on a grassy lot surrounded by trees and shrubs. The exterior features light yellow siding and a blue door. A wooden deck with an umbrella offers a shaded outdoor space, inviting relaxation in a serene setting.