Beachfront holiday rentals in Bay Shore

Rrezarta was amazing she is warm and welcoming and very helpful. The apartment has all the stuff you need for a family and beach stuff too!

Great stay! We had a wonderful time. The home was in a very convenient location. Easy to get to from the ferry, close to the main restaurants and beach, but still far enough to feel quiet and private. The home was clean and had many little details that made our stay cozy and welcoming. Bikes and beach chairs were wonderful for a beach getaway on Fire Island. Outdoor shower had hot water which was very nice since we were visiting preseason. Host was very responsive and helpful. We have stayed in many different places on Fire Island in the past and are very happy we found this home and host. We look forward to booking again in the future.

My friend and I had a great stay at Frank's house. Coming from NYC, it was wonderful to have such a peaceful and quiet spot to relax. We enjoyed walking to the nearby marina to observe the family of swans and to the small sandy beach. The beds were very comfortable and the house was clean and well-equipped to cook. We were glad we rented a car as there wasn't much in walking distance in terms of restaurants and grocery stores, but there were plenty of options within a 5-15 minute drive. Highly recommend Frank's house for a Long Island escape!

This cottage is absolutely lovely and peaceful. You have a view of the Long Island Sound across the street and the house sits on an inlet. We truly enjoy sitting on the back deck on the inlet water. There are ALWAYS people walking, riding bikes, jogging, walking dogs… etc Lots of delicious restaurants and stores so super close! We will definitely be booking here again in the future!

Ashley’s house is the perfect get away. I booked this house for my family to stay for my wedding weekend. My mom had never stayed in an Airbnb before and I’ve never seen her so happy and relaxed. She truly enjoyed her first Airbnb experience at Ashley’s place. It was exactly as described and the view is beautiful. Ashley was very responsive and made sure to answer any questions I had.

Had a lovely time in the Hamptons! Tasha was an amazing host- easiest check in/out, very responsive, and gave great recommendations for places in the area. Would love to stay here again!

Roberto was such a great host! The house was so cute and perfect for six people. It’s right off the water taxi stop, which was so convenient for getting to and from cherry grove (abt a 30 min ride to cherry grove, abt $20 per person). It’s also very close to a great beach. We would definitely stay again! Thank you Roberto!

Nice place. Clean and close to things to do

Very very good Airbnb experience. The house is cosy, organized and well loved and the gardens/pool are serenely beautiful. It’s the perfect spot. I’d recommend highly.

Geoffrey and Thomas were very gracious hosts, filled with benevolence, they greeted us with such warmth, gave us a tour of their beautiful home, along with the complimentary beverages, providing us with resources as well as information about the island since we’re newcomers, the house was lovely, clean and serene, hot tub was amazing, we enjoyed hearing their stories about fire island as well as giving us recommendations for food, shopping and sightseeing, it’s good to know fellow New Yorkers will have your back, very happy we picked their place to stay, absolutely would come back.

If we don't give a good review, can we keep this to ourselves?! Patti was a perfect host; the views were fantastic, whether from the outdoor porch or inside through the French doors looking out on the water. Access to the small beach and pool were excellent and we were close to several good restaurants (many of which Patti suggested, including some on the water) for take-out during the pandemic. Wifi was great and everything was very clean and as advertised. We generally fly for vacations and long weekends but had to stay closer to home this year and this was a perfect choice.

I got married this past Sunday at Mamaroneck Beach and Yacht club this past Sunday and we booked both of his units. I have a big family and we also booked another place 6 minutes away to accommodate everyone. He was so helpful and worked with me on answering all my questions and making the bookings very easy. When I say we were so impressed with his space, that’s an understatement. They even had a basket of goodies with a card and wine. I got videos and was supposed to come back to take photos but was so busy with my wedding preparations that I didn’t get to return back to do it. It’s definitely home away from home for my family while they were there! You can tell they take pride in sharing their home and their spaces with their guests! Would definitely highly recommend his beautiful place! Thank again John!!! We appreciate you and your wife for sharing your space with us!!

Dan is the most responsive host we've ever had. Usually we got a reply within minutes or even seconds. He happily got the hot tub heated up for us when we needed it and replenished our towels within an hour of our request. That hospitality made our stay so much better. The home is beautiful! It's right on the water, and features lots of luxurious tile, a huge patio, a little dock and lots of windows and open space from which to see it all. We especially loved the hot tub. I wouldn't hesitate to stay again if I'm ever on Long Island again.

This beautifully designed house blends warm, modern furnishings with sunlit spaces, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere that feels like home in the heart of nature. Traveling with family, including two young children, was a breeze thanks to the thoughtful inclusion of toys and board games, which added to the convenience and enjoyment of our stay. The kitchen has everything you need to entertain and the backyard BBQ was a cherry on top.

the house was extremely comfortable...quiet yet close to town and a 5 minute easy walk to the beach. it's a little small, with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath, but well-appointed. the pool is gorgeous. shawn was extremely responsive to any questions we had .

Great and responsive host. Home was lovely and we felt welcome. Host responded quickly to questions and requests. The home was very peaceful and relaxing. We really enjoyed the outdoor patio and pool area. I would recommend for a peaceful time away from the city.

Had a nice stay here with a group of people attending a wedding a short drive away.

⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 5/5 – Immaculate Stay & Top-Tier Hospitality I can’t recommend Anthony’s place highly enough. The space was immaculate—spotlessly clean, thoughtfully designed, and incredibly comfortable. Every room was even better than expected: • The infrared sauna in the modern bathroom felt like a luxury spa experience. • The kitchen was sleek, bright, and fully equipped, perfect for quick meals or longer stays. • The bedroom, bathed in soft blue ambient lighting, created the most relaxing sleep environment I’ve had in a while. • The living area was stylish, cozy, and equipped with a large flatscreen TV—ideal for winding down. Anthony was an outstanding host—warm, communicative, and quick to respond to any questions. From check-in to check-out, everything was seamless. Whether you’re traveling for work, wellness, or a quiet getaway, this space delivers on all fronts. I’ll absolutely be back.

Christine was very welcoming and I very much enjoyed my stay! The carriage house apartment was even more spacious and attractive than in the photos. We also appreciated the helpful messages we received. This accommodation is definitely worth the price!

Beautiful place. Pristine. Comfortable Short walk to the beach. Unfortunately because of rain we didn’t get to enjoy the lovely back yard. Owners were very good at getting back to us with any questions we had And being able to have a later check out really helped! Would definitely recommend this home and would love to find a reason to ho back again!!

We enjoyed our stay at Sue's and Danny's place. The beach is very special with beautiful sunsets, and the cabin is equipped with everything we needed for our stay. A great weekend getaway!

Mario was an incredible host! Immediately responsive and encouraging of my relaxing getaway steps from the beach. Plenty of towels and beach chairs for my family. Great grill space for the kids to hang out while I cooked dinner before walking to town for ice cream.

Heather’s home was so lovely! There were so many thoughtful details from soft linens, extra pillows, everything you could need for the beach and a delightful welcome basket. We could see and hear the ocean and overall it was so relaxing and beautiful. I hope we can return again.

Thank you so much for everything!! We had the most incredible stay! 1000/10. The wine and snacks were so lovely:) we truly felt so at home! We are already talking about returning because of how nice the bnb was! So many thoughtful touches:)