
Holiday rentals in Fairy Island
Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb
Top-rated holiday rentals in Fairy Island
Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

YurtSimple
YurtSimple is where life slows down and people unplug. It’s forest bathing in nature. It’s getting away from it all to spend time with a partner, by oneself, and sometimes with pets. You’ll be driving past YurtCation (about 300 feet past YurtCation) to get to YurtSimple. YurtCation is 20’ in diameter and YurtSimple is 16’ in diameter. Wood and charcoal are provided. You may cook on the indoor wood stove top, or visit any number of great restaurants 2 miles away. You can even order pizza delivery

Pet-Friendly Retreat•Sleeps 8•Huge Yard•Fire pit
Wake up to sunrise over a peaceful backyard and enjoy your morning coffee on the private balcony. Evenings are perfect by the fire pit under a starry sky. Just a 5 minute drive from Pewaukee Lake Pet-friendly home with a large yard and fire pit - ideal for relaxing and spending time together. Open-concept living, kitchen, and dining area creates a warm, inviting space to gather. Sleeps up to 8 and is best suited for small families or close-knit groups who prefer a more cozy, intimate layout.

Lake Lovers Hideaway near Lake Geneva
Perfect getaway with all the camping and lake amenities. Enjoy the sights and sounds of the Kettle Moraine with a clean and spacious hot tub, fire pit, propane grill, and activities to keep you busy. Even better, Lauderdale Lake access is less than a mile away with a pier for fishing, kayak for exploring, or bring your own boat for more lake fun! With parking space enough for two cars and a boat, day boat slip access, and Wisconsin favorites ready for you on arrival, you won't be disappointed!

Red Lodge-Game Room, Hot Tub, Near Lakes!
Conveniently located amidst Southeast Wisconsin's best attractions, The Red Lodge is a contemporary-styled retreat that offers the space and family-friendly amenities to keep everyone entertained for hours. Enjoy an 👾 room, a secondary game room, a hot tub, a fire 🔥 pit, and a BBQ pit. Rent a boat right in the neighborhood at Lauderdale Lakes. Bike and hike at Kettle Moraine State Forest. Visit Lake Geneva for golfing and shopping—a quick 20-25 min drive away. Alpine Valley is minutes away!

Camp Wandawega: Lakeside 3 Bedroom Cabin
Overlooking the lake nestled right behind the main lodge, this cabin has 3 bedrooms, a half bathroom, a seating a room, a basic kitchenette & access to camp showers downstairs. One large bedroom has a queen bed, one room with bunkbeds, & one with a full bed to accommodate a max of 6 guests. (But the bunkbeds are best for kid-sized humans). Like all of Wandawega, it’s a back-to-basics, no-frills, primitive experience. Simple rooms, vintage furnishings. There is heat & a couple AC window units.

Exquisite Modern A-frame all WithInnReach
An amazing space that truly caters to the guest experience. We've built this art piece to have our guests immerse themselves in all the amenities, from heated floors to in-ceiling speakers - all whilst losing yourself in the wood burning fireplace. At WithInnReach the attention to detail was paramount - with an emphasis of what we enjoy...amazing food through a well balanced kitchen, beautiful sound through Klipsch speakers and relaxation with floor to ceiling showers...enjoy to the fullest.

The Retreat: 5 Acre Log Cabin
Escape to this beautiful 5-acre country retreat, located a short drive from Lauderdale Lakes, Alpine Valley, and Lake Geneva. The cabin features two kitchens, two family rooms, a year around outdoor hot tub, a game room, and five bedrooms with comfortable king-sized beds. The master suite also includes a steam room for added luxury. Spend your days enjoying the great outdoors with a game of beach volleyball or roasting marshmallows around a bonfire, while taking in the fresh midwestern air.

The Butterfly Cottage
Your winter get-away is perfect at The Butterfly Cottage on Honey Lake! Relax and enjoy the serenity of the lake and all the natural beauty of the season! This is a cozy cottage on Honey Lake, just 4 miles from downtown Burlington and 13 miles from Lake Geneva. Alpine Valley for skiing and concerts, fishing on Honey Lake or nearby Browns Lake as well as shopping in Lake Geneva are the highlights of the season! There are hiking/walking trails all around as well as rustic roads to explore.

Lakeside Getaway
Relax with the whole family at this peaceful, home on Lake Beulah. With the gorgeous lake and surrounding nature, you will feel you are hours up North, minus the long commute! Wake up and enjoy coffee on the deck. Bring your boat or grab a floaty and soak up the sun as you spend the day on the water. Wind down while you watch a stunning sunset from your own pier. Enjoy a show at the nearby Alpine Valley. Countless memories are just waiting to be made. Come play hard and relax even harder

Cozy Country Cottage near Lake Geneva, WI
Our Cozy Cottage features 3 comfortable bedrooms and nightly magnificent sunsets. Nestled on a country road, the house offers plenty of space to rest after visiting Lake Geneva, Lauderdale lakes, biking at Kettle Moraine or site seeing in the area. It’s close to Walworth County fair grounds where the flea market, Das Fest and Rib Fest are held. This is country living with plenty of opportunity to enjoy the beautiful outdoors or the peace and quiet of the countryside.

Long Lake Retreat - Cottage in Burlington, WI
Long Lake Retreat Kick back and soak up the laid-back lake life at our cozy cottage right on the water in beautiful Burlington, Wisconsin! Just a short drive from downtown Burlington, Waterford, and Lake Geneva, you'll find great local spots to eat, shop, and explore. But with a lake out your back door and nature all around, you might just spend your whole trip outside! Come unwind, unplug, and enjoy lake life!

Cozy Lake Geneva Cottage | Near Lake & Town
Step back in time in this cozy retreat, filled with vintage charm that is tucked away near the peaceful Historic Maple District. Perfect for couples, small groups and families. The Location: 0.9 Miles to Geneva Lake & Downtown: A flat, scenic stroll through the beautiful Historic Maple District - Many guests love the walk! 8 min to Grand Geneva Resort & Spa18 min to Burlington 20 min to Alpine Valley
Popular amenities for Fairy Island holiday rentals
Other great holiday rentals in Fairy Island

Charming Retreat Steps from Lake & Downtown Gems

Marie's Cottage

Lakefront 4-Bedroom Retreat with Hot Tub

Chic Condo in Lake Geneva.

The Shed at Little Farm Fontana

Serene Lakefront House on Fox Lake W/ Private Dock

Peaceful Horse Farm Stay Private & Quiet

Lake Geneva Hideaway
Destinations to explore
- Chicago Holiday rentals
- Upper Peninsula Holiday rentals
- Platteville Holiday rentals
- Indianapolis Holiday rentals
- Downtown Chicago Holiday rentals
- Detroit Holiday rentals
- Minneapolis Holiday rentals
- Wisconsin River Holiday rentals
- Milwaukee Holiday rentals
- Windsor Holiday rentals
- Traverse City Holiday rentals
- Ann Arbor Holiday rentals
- Six Flags Great America
- Alpine Valley Resort
- Wilmot Mountain Ski Resort
- Illinois Beach State Park
- Erin Hills Golf Course
- Naval Station Great Lakes
- Milwaukee County Zoo
- Lake Kegonsa State Park
- Milwaukee Public Museum
- Baird Center
- Bradford Beach
- Sunburst
- Discovery World
- Marquette University
- American Family Field
- Riverside Theater
- Fiserv Forum
- Gurnee Mills
- Holy Hill National Shrine of Mary
- Lake Geneva Public Library
- Lake Geneva Cruise Line
- American Family Insurance Amphitheater
- Little Switzerland Ski Area
- South Shore Park




