Beachfront holiday rentals in Gilgo-Oak Beach-Captree

Great stay! We had a wonderful time. The home was in a very convenient location. Easy to get to from the ferry, close to the main restaurants and beach, but still far enough to feel quiet and private. The home was clean and had many little details that made our stay cozy and welcoming. Bikes and beach chairs were wonderful for a beach getaway on Fire Island. Outdoor shower had hot water which was very nice since we were visiting preseason. Host was very responsive and helpful. We have stayed in many different places on Fire Island in the past and are very happy we found this home and host. We look forward to booking again in the future.

We had a wonderful stay at this cozy, newly remodeled home in Mastic Beach, NY. The house was spotless, fully equipped, and located on a quiet street—perfect for a relaxing getaway. Each bedroom was comfortable with its own AC/heating unit, which made it easy to keep everyone happy. The owner was incredibly kind and accommodating. The only small downside was that there was no washer and dryer available for use. Otherwise, everything was fantastic. Highly recommend this place for a peaceful and comfortable stay!

Danny’s place was beautiful and looked exactly like the photos. The location was perfect—right on the beach with plenty to do nearby. Just a heads-up: it gets a bit chilly at night, so bring a sweater. Overall, it was a great stay, and I can’t wait to book again!

Had a wonderful weekend away from the city in Long Beach. Airbnb was in a quiet area close to the beach and easy to get to the LIRR & west end. Jenna was super kind and responsive. We will be back!

Very nice place and great host. Would recommend

Joseph was extremely helpful during our stay and made himself available to help us as needed with any problems that occurred. Would highly recommend Joseph as a host!

Arthur was quick and easy to communicate from the beginning of starting our vacation search. He gave simple helpful check in and check out instructions. Nice location, walkable to 1 of 3 beaches wecfound in the area. Arthur helped do research on a great Thai restaurant, suggested sites to see, etc and was always pleasant just to chat with.

We had an amazing weekend at Sol’s Place! The house is in the perfect spot, sitting right above the beach - which you can reach by taking some steps down. The big terrace was definitely a highlight, with unbelievable views over Long Island Sound, perfect for catching those amazing sunrises and sunsets. The house itself is super nice. The beds were really comfy, the kitchen had everything we needed, and the shower was just perfect. Sol was an awesome host, always quick to respond to any questions. He gave us some great recommendations for local spots and restaurants. All in all, it was a fantastic stay and we can totally recommend it.

Very very good Airbnb experience. The house is cosy, organized and well loved and the gardens/pool are serenely beautiful. It’s the perfect spot. I’d recommend highly.

The house was beautiful and even nicer than the pictures. We loved the pool and the beach was right there. Tim was super responsive- especially around check in time. Would easily stay there again next time i am im the area !

Geoffrey and Thomas were very gracious hosts, filled with benevolence, they greeted us with such warmth, gave us a tour of their beautiful home, along with the complimentary beverages, providing us with resources as well as information about the island since we’re newcomers, the house was lovely, clean and serene, hot tub was amazing, we enjoyed hearing their stories about fire island as well as giving us recommendations for food, shopping and sightseeing, it’s good to know fellow New Yorkers will have your back, very happy we picked their place to stay, absolutely would come back.

A group of six of us stayed at Matt and Nick’s for Memorial Day weekend and absolutely loved it. The first floor has two large bedrooms with comfortable king beds and large en suite bathrooms. The second floor has a twin bunk room with a half bath, as well as a kitchen and living area with an incredible view of the ocean. Outside, there is a grill, outdoor shower, and a large pool (heated, which is rare in the pines). Nick and Matt were also super responsive to questions throughout our stay. We will definitely be staying there again when we visit. Five stars!

We enjoyed our stay in this beautiful home near New York City. Comfortably furnished and pleasantly decorated, with a well furnished kitchen and there were even games for the kids. The host was responsive and helpful. We enjoyed the beautiful views of the harbor filled with sailboats from the park next door and my kids loved the playground too!

This is a perfect spot in a magical place. Honestly the photos don’t do it justice. The views from the house are stunning. The deck is incredible and I loved listening to ocean waves all day and night. My friends and I had a great time. Will definitely be back! Thanks again.

the house was extremely comfortable...quiet yet close to town and a 5 minute easy walk to the beach. it's a little small, with 2 bedrooms and 1 bath, but well-appointed. the pool is gorgeous. shawn was extremely responsive to any questions we had .

Great and responsive host. Home was lovely and we felt welcome. Host responded quickly to questions and requests. The home was very peaceful and relaxing. We really enjoyed the outdoor patio and pool area. I would recommend for a peaceful time away from the city.

I spent a long weekend with my mother and two adult daughters revisiting my hometown of Northport. We loved our stay here! Downtown is a couple blocks away but it's quiet at night, waterfront location was beautiful, and we enjoyed the whimsy of having our own bar and putting green. Janine and Steve were attentive and helpful but not intrusive. One thing I didn't pick up on from the photos is the sleeper sofa is in the same room as the bed. For four close family gals, this wasn't an issue for us. Highly recommend.

The apartment was very clean and beautiful. The check-in was simple and easy. The communication with Nakeita and Lateef was great. The view from the deck was nice, and we really enjoyed our stay. Would definitely return if we are in the area.

We came to Long Beach to spend the weekend with our son from Manhattan. He had an easy time getting to Long Beach on the LIRR. Access from JFK was also fairly easy. House had plenty of room for all of us. Easy access to beach. Short walk to boardwalk. Several bars and restaurants within walking distance. Lots of options.

SAND IN THE TOES IS THE BEST VACATION SPOT YOU WILL FIND! We had the best stay and are already looking to book our next 💓

If you are looking to explore New York for a few days or longer then Jay's place is great. Just a few minutes from the Long Beach station, Penn or Grand Central are about an hour away on a direct LIRR train. You will save $$$ by staying here compared with Manhattan. Long Beach is a safe, full of interesting shops. The 10km boardwalk is just a few minutes away. The apartment of character in a listed building full of charm. Loved the well stocked kitchen and would not hesitate to come back again.

Tanya's place was a charming, private beach house tucked away in the corner of Atlantique with beautiful bay views. We know Fire Island very well, so it was easy for us to find the property; however, Tanya is very responsive and helpful when you arrive. Although the house has no extra frills, the place has everything you need to enjoy a quiet beach weekend including a beautiful deck. Atlantique is about a mile walk from Ocean Beach and Fair Harbor where you can find restaurants and small shops.

This very unique home is full of charm and history. The furnishings are beautiful. Our family totally enjoyed our stay on the Great South Bay & plan a future stay.

This place was absolutely stunning—far beyond what I expected! The house was immaculate, and the decor perfectly matched my birthday theme, which made the stay feel extra special. I’m already planning to come back in the summer to fully enjoy the beach. Highlights: The beds were incredibly comfortable—I sank right in and slept like a dream. We were lucky enough to spot swans and their babies on the ocean, which was such a beautiful moment. The backyard was gorgeous, and since the sun made an appearance, I got to enjoy the picnic bench. The large windows let in so much natural light and offered lovely views. The host was communicative, kind, and genuinely welcoming. If you’re looking for a peaceful beach getaway, I 100% recommend this place. Can’t wait to return!