Cabin holiday rentals in West Milford

Rob & Jen’s Cozy Creek Cabin was just as gorgeous as the photos if not more picturesque! Quiet, tranquil, and secluded. We saw lots of deer with several fawns… one was hidden for the day in the rocks right outside the cabin. We saw mama come and get her at dusk! Close to Camelback activities, but tucked away in the woods. The hosts were super friendly and responsive. If you’re considering this cabin, do it! You won’t regret it!!!

I stayed here for 4 nights and had such a fun time. The house was beautiful and decorated so nicely, you can tell the owners really love their home. Stacy is a great communicator, her instructions and recommendations were easy to follow. Overall my friends and I had a great girls trip, I’d definitely recommend staying here!

Great place to stay in the woods, easy to find, and a very welcoming environment. I recommend it highly to anyone interested in the area.

This was the best BNB we have ever stayed at! Very clean, comfortable, private, and beautiful. You can tell thought was put into every detail. We didn't want to leave! The beds were very comfortable, we even ordered the same bedding with the BNB Cozy Earth discount code that was in the bedroom once we got home (Thank you, Meng!). The location was also great and not too far from anything with a lot of scenic natural beauty. We stopped at the North Branch Cider Mill nearby for coffee and some shopping and that's now my favorite stop in the Catskills! We hope to be back again soon. 10/10!

~5 Star Cabin in the Woods~ Beautiful, secluded property with a pristine natural waterfall right in the backyard! The fire pit and hot tub are our favs. The entire place is SPOTLESS! The extra fresh towels and comfy bed linens are a lovely bonus. Plus, a fully stocked kitchen! Bill is an amazing host. He thought of everything that you could ever need! He was super responsive, informative, and accommodated all of our needs. Can’t wait to return!!!

This place the atmosphere the surroundings it was all so lovely and needed, the price paid off. I loved the views the water and the shower outside. The bed was so comfortable very clean the place overall was very comfy I felt so comfortable. I recommend this place for a stay if you love to be away from people and need calmness. Everything was on spot from the house, the area outside to everything included. Thankyou so much for this, 10/10

Great little cabin in the Poconos. Very spacious living room and kitchen area. Morgan was a great host and was very easy to communicate with. The only issue is that it is a huge development and the pools are a little bit of a ride to get to. Even with that we had a great time and would definitely be interested in staying there again.

Julie's place was the perfect winter getaway. The fireplace, hot tub and sauna warmed us and the very well-equipped kitchen enabled us to prepare great meals. The house was beautiful, with two living rooms for different activities and energy levels, a game room downstairs, a dining room with a large table and chairs, and comfortable furniture and beds throughout. Julie texted me to make sure that our every need was met. We had a snow and ice storm, and she had the driveway and walkways plowed, shoveled and sanded twice, and kept plenty of salt on-hand. We hope to return sometime in warmer weather so we can enjoy the pond, too.

Stayed here 4 times now and always look forward to it. The peaceful surroundings and comfort of the cabin are a great escape from the city. Also just a short drive to Shohola falls, Milford and Dingmans ferry for shopping and hiking then coming back to the cabin to grill and hangout on the deck. Already looking forward to coming back. We had a few simple questions and Glen is always quick to respond..

We were two families from NYC that spend three nights at this place. The house was more than spacious for the 8 of us and we thoroughly enjoyed the four person hot tub, the firepit and badminton set. The kitchen was really well equipped for cooking and the beds were super comfortable. John was just a text away for any questions.

Was exactly the weekend getaway we needed. The tub was perfect for the cold nights, and we were just close enough to do a few hikes. The cabin was exceptionally clean and James was very attentive to anything that we needed. It is definitely in a neighborhood, and there are many families that live by but because of the greenery and the way that the house is laid out it feels very private. We would recommend this to friends and family! Thank you, James!

Our family gets a cabin in upstate NY every summer to escape the city life and this was by far everyone's favorite summer cabin so far. The property is beautiful and quiet. Patrick made the process very easy and the cabin is so warm and welcoming. Our dog LOVED swimming in the stream and playing in the yard with the kids.

We spent a long weekend at the Rustic Rust cabin with some extended family and our two dogs. The cabin was charming and well equipped, and it felt like a true retreat. We loved the decor and the stunning landscaping surrounding the creek. The children had a blast, exploring the outdoors and searching for fish in Marshalls Creek. The cabin had a well stocked kitchen, and there were plenty of linens in each bedroom and towels in each bathroom. The owners provided us with information on local fishing spots and there were plenty of brochures about local activities in the home. The dogs appreciated the attention to detail with towels, bowls, and poop bags. We will be back!

Katherine was a wonderful host, and her Barryville home was the perfect getaway for our family. From the moment we walked in, we felt welcomed—the thoughtful breakfast treats waiting for us were such a kind touch and set the tone for our stay. The cabin itself is spotless, tastefully decorated, and stocked with everything we could possibly need. Katherine was always quick to respond and happy to accommodate our questions and requests. Her flexibility and warm communication made planning our days easy. :) If you’re looking for a peaceful retreat with a responsive host, delightful personal touches, and a home base that feels both rustic and refined, Katherine’s place is perfect. We’re already talking about coming back!!

This was my second time at this cabin. Everyone is so nice and welcoming. The dock is great with all the boats and floats. We definitely will be making this a yearly trip.

This was exactly the break that my family needed for a couple of days. I loved having no TV and lots of opportunities to hike to see waterfalls and fresh air! The kitchen was well set up for meals at home. It was chilly and rained most of the time, but we played cards and talked - so great! We were able to have an outdoor fire the last night and it was perfect! My only recommendation (and this has nothing to do with the cute house) for people coming to the area is to bring some printed maps as the area has very little cell phone coverage and we might have missed some of what we wanted to see as we simply couldn't find it. The falls we hiked (Hackers, Raymondskill, Dingmans and Silver Thread) were amazing! I would rent this place again!

We had a relaxing stay here. The view was lovely and house was exactly as described. The hosts were very responsive too.

The Nordic Cabin was the perfect setting for my husband and I to celebrate our 22nd wedding anniversary. The cabin is beautiful and the modern design, furnishings, and decor really stand out. Instructions of how to get into the cabin and the pitcures provided made check in and check out a breeze. The kitchen was well stocked. A bottle of white wine and a few treats were left for us. The kitchen offered different spices, oils, milk, and eggs. Kitchen utensils, pots/pans, dishes, cups, glasses, etc are provided, as well as cleaning supplies. The bathroom was stocked with toiletries. We spent a lot of time relaxing in the cozy living room and slept well in the beautiful bedroom. Last, I have to say that the first time we opened the gate at night, after dinner in Warwick, and saw all of the outdoor lights on, really made it feel like we were entering an enchanted garden. Would definitely come back!! Thank you Kamil and Margaret!!

A wonderful stay, so quiet and peaceful. Very much needed, the host helped out with any and every question we had and made sure we were taken care of.

The place was as described in the listing. The house is out in nature but not far from local restaurants and stores. The kids loved seeing the wildlife around the house, like chipmunks and groundhogs. We even saw a black bear from the dining room window.

This beautiful Cabin was just magical. We walked in and right away felt at ease and got the sense that we were on vacation. This home is beautifully appointed and has a sense of nostalgia with the original woodwork mixed with modern and upscale finishes. There was immense attention to detail in the atmosphere, and a flow to the home. I appreciated it very much. Our hosts were very responsive to all communication and we felt well cared for. We were welcomed with a lovely gift of coffee from a local roaster and we enjoyed it over the course of our stay. It rained the entire time we were there but it didn't put a damper on our stay at all as being inside this cabin was enough to keep us content. Great views of the lake were really great to enjoy from the enclosed sunroom. Thankful for the opportunity.

Had an incredible stay at this Airbnb. It was supremely relaxing and a great way to disconnect and slow down. The house was beautiful, great amenities, scenic, and serene with views of trees all around. The best however was Greyson - before even been booking the house, we were sent a list of restaurants/activities/hiking trails in the area. Additionally, every message sent to the host received an immediate reply. The hosts have impeccable taste as you can see with the furnishings of the house. Highly recommend.

This cabin was very cozy and the surrounding area was very scenic and pretty, as well as quiet and peaceful. Kerri allowed my group of friends to shoot our short film outside the house, and it was a great location for filming as well as a great place for some of the crew members to stay overnight and hangout after shoot. We didn't have much free time but we were provided with lots of recommendations of places to checkout nearby and I'd love to maybe rent the place again sometime to explore the scenery. The neighbors were friendly and Kerri gave us very clear and useful information about the house to make our stay easy.

We had a wonderful stay! The host’s instructions were clear and easy to follow, and everything was just as expected. I’ve stayed at this house before and returned this time with friends—everyone had a great time. The home was clean, comfortable, and perfect for a relaxing weekend in the Catskills. Would definitely come back again!