Hotel holiday rentals in Fire Island

Amazing stay, this hotel is great! The pool was like a bathtub and the owners kept it open late so I could swim after 8PM! Will be coming back again and again.

Very clean place the property was quiet and kept up. Friendly staff with great recommendations. Would definitely stay there again.

Location is perfect. Room was clean and staff on site was very friendly. The parking is valet and there is a fee for that. This hotel room is kinda old tho, the sink in the bathroom is always clogged. The A/C is either super hot or super cold.

Excellent stay — would happily book again!

Kind staffs and clean place to stay!

Amazing stay! Friendly staff and location can’t be beat!

We have stayed at Michael's place before and always find it a clean, comfortable place to stay while visiting with family.

2nd time staying here and all is good! 1st time was for a week and this time for 8 nights. Only recommendation would be I’d like a bigger fridge since it is an Airbnb for an extended stay otherwise no complaints! Will be back.

Everything all peaceful. Amazing experience. Thank you for providing this listing on the platform. We like it.

This is the best location on this side of the north fork. Unbeatable proximity to the beach. The bed is also big and comfortable. Matter of fact the whole room is large. It could use some upgrades but it has those two most important things. Oh! And good food on site! It’s also close to town and to 67 step beach. I will definitely be back in the warmer weather!

Enjoyed our stay. The staff was very helpful and friendly. They were also very kind to my dog. Would recommend to anyone staying in the area.

I HIGHLY recommend staying at Temperance Hall when in Bellport! Not only is the entire place beautifully charming, but so are Alison and Joanne. Perfect location (very walkable) and check-in was a breeze. My room (The Old Inlet) was huge, spotless and had a private entrance, so I could come and go as I pleased. And Alison and Joanne are amaaaaazzzzing hosts -- very responsive and highly entertaining (with great Bellport stories/history). I will definitely be back!

Good clean hotel with great smiling staff and really good breakfast and coffee in the morning. Has an indoor pool and a gym. Would stay here again for sure.

A very nice hotel, room was very clean. the host was very helpful with my questions and I appreciate that they allowed me to check-in an hour early. will definitely book again.

Good price and clean area

Excellent, I recommend 100/100🙌🏼🙌🏼. I come back soon .. I really liked their cleanliness and the comfort that the rooms have, especially La Paz that feels like😍.

Daminder’s place was nice. We felt right at home. The rooms were clean and there was quiet and peace. I would stay here again and would recommend to family and friends who want to stay in the area.

Excellent location. Updated. Clean. Well designed. Organized and exactly as described. Will definitely be back! Highly recommended. Thank you

Loved my time at the Driftwood - spacious room - amazing deck and view of the sunrise - clean, peaceful and quiet and right on the ocean!! Also, close to towns in either direction - Montauk and Amagansett and East Hampton - will definitely be back!!

Had a wonderful stay! The hosts were great—check-in was smooth and easy. The cottage was spotless, well-maintained, and fully stocked with everything we needed. The property itself is beautiful and peaceful, and the tennis court was a fantastic bonus. Would definitely stay here again!

We had a great stay at Three Ducks! Everything is brand new and the location is great in Westhampton. The staff were very accommodating and the room had everything we needed.

We had the best time at the Moonrise. We’re already thinking about when to book our next stay. Our expectations were met and more. The staff are so friendly and accommodating. Would recommend this place for a wonderful Fire Island experience.

This place is ok if your on a budget. The area is worth a million dollars but the motel was a motel. Although the staff and other people were very friendly. It felt very very safe there. Lots of kids for my kids to play with and a pool. Id coke back for the beach.