Private suite holiday rentals in Fire Island

Holly’s place was gorgeous and very peaceful! She was a great host, very kind and quick to respond. Beautiful property! Hope to be back again.

Jennifer’s place is very clean and comfortable. Great location—the LIRR, restaurants, supermarket, beach, and library are all walkable from the AirBNB. Jennifer is a very thoughtful host. I loved that the bedding and towels were fragrance-free. She also lent her beach towels, chairs and umbrella (and beach passes when needed)—such a wonderful perk!

We enjoyed our stay so much and hope to be back! Hosts communicated very fast & helpful!

This suite was just what we needed for a 1-night stay during our friends' wedding weekend. It's a short car ride from the Huntington LIRR Station and walking distance to a breakfast and lunch spot called Kerber's Farm that was delicious! Most importantly, Liz, Alexx, and Will were easy to communicate with and very kindly accommodated our request for an early check-in so we could drop off our luggage before the wedding ceremony. Their flexibility and hospitality were greatly appreciated. Amenities like the filtered water cooler and snacks upon arrival make a real difference and were the cherry on top of an already wonderful stay.

We love staying at George’s place, it feels just like home away from home for us. We’ve visited this property several times over the years, most recently with our son who’s now old enough to fully enjoy the yard on his own. He had a fantastic time playing outside, talking to the deer and rabbits that came to visit. We even saw some turkey vultures! Overall a solid place to stay and it’s become somewhat of a family tradition. Thank you George!

Sandy was great. The place was clean. I underestimated the size of the place for the length of time we stayed. We stayed a whole month and it was very small for my husband and I. It’s a good place to stay for a weekend or even a week. Otherwise the place was good. Private and clean

Lori is a great host and highly responsive. Very cozy place! It has everything you need. Bed was also extremely comfortable. Felt very safe and private. An added bonus is it’s super close to the Main Street of Patchogue. Highly recommend!

Bill is a great host and very responsive and detailed in the instructions for arriving, checking in, entry, and description. We had a great time and wished we could stay longer! Everything was so comfy and clean, and we loved the breakfast foods provided (ie: buttered bread, yogurt, banana, oranges, milk, and coffee). It felt right at home! We would not hesitate to come visit again in the future!

My husband and I were in town for a retirement party and we feel so fortunate that we found Joy and Ronnie’s Airbnb! Everything was absolutely perfect for us and the space was decorated so nicely with great amenities. We were very comfortable. Our hosts were super friendly and communication was A1! We will definitely be returning and recommend this Airbnb. Thank you both so much for a wonderfully pleasant stay!

Peaceful and cozy! The chickens were adorable and it was a very short walk to downtown Patchogue where all the restaurants are. Lovely backyard. Very clean place, spacious, comfortable and the refreshments were such a sweet touch.

I had a wonderful 2-night stay at this Airbnb! The place was exactly as described—clean, cozy, and very comfortable. Everything was well-prepared and thoughtfully arranged, which made me feel right at home. The location was great and made it easy to explore the area. Communication with the host was smooth and responsive throughout. I truly enjoyed my time here and will definitely book again on my next visit. Highly recommend!

Tim and Lorna were excellent hosts! The place was better than expected and in a great area centrally located on the island. There were so many thoughtful little details they provided for both me and my my furbaby - from toys and a bed for him to all sorts of things we might forget when traveling (first aide kit, lint brush and so much more). The place was impeccable and very comfortable. My plans changed when I arrived and I needed up just relaxing for quite a bit of my stay and it was perfect. A very comfortable sitting area with books, games and a tv with lots of options. The bedroom was roomy and very comfortable. I slept like a baby throughout my stay as it is a nice quiet area and I barely heard anything from them as they are upstairs. There is a coffee maker, small fridge and microwave which was all I needed since I wasn’t looking to cook while away. They were very responsive when I misunderstood the instructions on how to get in. I will most certainly be back!

Sahaja’s place is located on a quiet residential street and there’s a convenient parking place right in front. Check-in was easy and she answered any questions quickly. The place is very clean and the bed is comfortable. The shower is great.

This side unit was convenient, comfortable, and charming. We were visiting for the weekend to attend a wedding in Smithtown. Our ETA was earlier than expected and Patricia was responsive and flexible for check-in. We drove and parked on-property (also walkable to the train if needed). The instructions were easy to follow and the unit had everything we needed & more— felt at-home while still providing hotel-quality service. We appreciated that they were on-site if we needed anything. We recommend for any small group/family!

We had a fantastic stay in Damon’s camper! Everything was very well organized, clean, and thoughtfully set up — it had everything we needed for a comfortable and cozy stay. Damon is a super responsive and kind host who made the whole experience easy and enjoyable. Highly recommended, and we’d love to come back next time we’re in Long Island.

Was a cute little basement area. Would book again.

Super clean and new-looking Airbnb. I’m not sure if they had recently renovated but looked brand new. It was very clean, private, and easy to find.

I stayed here longterm and it was a great experience. The space is nice and very cozy with a warm homey feel. The neighborhood is quiet and peaceful, perfect for relaxing. It had everything I needed for a comfortable stay. The host was very kind and incredibly accommodating. When a couple things did come up during my stay, he handled it. You can tell he genuinely cares about his guests. I would definitely recommend this place.

The home is in a beautiful and quiet neighborhood. All amenities were as described and Sara took the time to ensure any directions needed were clearly detailed. She was responsive and timely with any needs or questions I had. I’d definitely stay here again if I make it back to Northport.

Everything was great and as described. Very clean, very close to the train station and we were able to explore different places in New York easily. I appreciate the generosity and acts of kindest we felt there. We will definitely come back.

Highly recommended! My boyfriend and I recently stayed at Jill's place for Memorial Day weekend. The photos in the listing are very accurate to how beautiful and clean the apartment was. Everything was spacious and well lit, and made everything about the stay comfortable. There were plentiful amenities, and everything you can possibly need for a few days stay, was available; including supplies for the kitchen, bathroom, bed, etc. The view of the pier is absolutely stunning, especially during the sunset. Between the beach, shops, and restaurants, everything in the area is within walking distance making it a very convenient location to stay. If you are looking to visit the main beach as part of your experience, beach passes are supplied. We did not end up needing chairs and umbrellas, but we do know they were available to guests. We did not have any questions/concerns during our stay, but we do know if we needed anything at all during our stay, Jill is readily available for contact.

Host was amazing. Everything in the house was clean. The host had helpful instructions on how to navigate within the Airbnb. Amazing host! I would book with them again for my next New York visit.

súper attentive hosts, we had a couple of circumstances affect our stay yet they were more than willing to make the accommodations that we needed. Went above and beyond to make us feel safe and welcomed. Would love to have them host again!

We are frequent guests and always have a good experience!