House holiday rentals in Kelleys Island

Joni’s place was perfect for what we were looking for! The place was very spacious - with the 1st double queen room being inside the front door, and the rest of the bedrooms upstairs. It wasn’t right downtown, but it was near the ferry which was perfect for us. Theres golf carts available on-site which is what we used to get downtown. The staff on site was very helpful. Joni sent detailed instructions leading up to our stay and was available during our stay. Would definitely recommend!

I stayed in this exact cottage as a kid and into my teen years (before the back space with w/d and extra bathroom was added). It has since changed owners many times, but man, I wish Brian had had this property all along! Fantastically helpful, check in and check out was a breeze, the place is equipped for everything you need to have fun as a fam (bikes, tennis rackets, scooters, pickleball paddles ...), the space was super functional, and the location is *chef's kiss*. No notes! 10/10. I can't wait for 2026 availability to drop so we can book 423 Cherry again (for the 21st summer!!).

We truly enjoyed the stay. Very thankful for their attention to detail and providing a great place to stay. We are looking forward to a return visit.

Had a wonderful week vacation at Island Club at Putin Bay. Nichole was a wonderful hostess!! Made everything about our reservation, check in and entire stay very easy and smooth and terrific communication. Highly recommend.. thanks Nichole!!

We stayed at their beautiful condo for our babymoon! Place was well taken care of, everything was easy to find! Walkable to the ferry and a lot of restaurants! We will definitely be back ☺️

We had a fantastic stay! The space was spotless, smelled amazing, and was incredibly spacious and comfortable—perfect for relaxing after a long day. The location couldn’t have been better, with everything we needed close by. The hosts were friendly, responsive, and made sure we had everything we needed for a smooth experience. Highly recommend and would absolutely stay again!

Absolutely the best, they made are vacation excellent. Heating the pool to hot tub. Everything was perfect and would love to stay again. Location was ideal for cedar point and Cleveland.

Kristen’s cottage is a great spot in Lakeside. It was just right for our family of 6 and everything was clean and well taken care of. There isn’t much space inside but that’s ok because Lakeside has so much to offer. A great house in a great vacation spot!

Bette than advertised. We stayed here for a fishing trip, we had 4 large boats and pickups. Albert let us park in the grass as needed. There was adequate outlets to charge our boat batteries at night and the garage space was excellent for the storage of our extra equipment, coolers, and gear. Beds are very comfortable, great furniture, and the house is nicely updated and decorated. We will definitely be staying here again!

very quiet neighborhood, clean spacious house. Parking was big enough for a truck and trailer. The garage was a bonus to keep motorcycle overnight. Great little place

I would recommend the place to everyone. It was nothing but a pleasure to stay there. Oh, and the beds were awesome.

Lovely view right next to the lake, very spacious home and well stocked kitchen! Would definitely love to be hosted again!

Scotts place was as advertised plus more. 5 adults were quite comfortable and you can’t beat the view. Location was great to get to our favorite Huron restaurants.

The Pink Bungalow is an adorable little house that is decorated beautifully and very comfortable with plenty of room for 6 adults. We loved the beach vibe. Having 3 bedrooms and 2 full baths is a plus for this location. The living room and bedroom furniture were very comfortable as well and the kitchen was well stocked with dishes, etc. We would stay here again!

We loved this house. Very quiet, beautiful location. Close to Cedar Point for our older kids, but relaxing and beautiful retreat for us as parents.

Dakota’s place was very clean and comfortable, perfect for our stay with 2 young families. The location was at the end of a street, near locations you’ll probably visit while staying in Port Clinton! Dakota was friendly and a great host. Thanks!

We had a wonderful time. Kitchen was well stocked and organized! We had plenty of towels and extra blankets that came in handy on those cold days. The kids were endlessly entertained with all the backyard activities. The host was very nice and able to answer our questions. Our families had a pleasant stay!

Very clean and close to the beach. Lots to do in and around the area. 32 minutes from Cedar Point. Fit our family of six perfectly with room to spare. The train system in the area is quite busy but they did not blow their horn thankfully. Would definitely rent here again.

The condo was very clean and the instructions were very clear. The pool and exercise room was very clean and convenient. The location was amazing with many restaurants and activities within walking distance.

The house was in the perfect location for going to Cedar Point! It was very clean and easy to get into, and we loved being able to bring our dog too. The restaurant and bar recommendations were great too. We will definitely stay here again whenever we make it back up to Sandusky!

wonderful stay! We really enjoyed our time here. Great pool (and tons of pool toys!) kept our kids busy when we weren't outgoing the tourist thing. Beds were comfortable, kitchen and bathrooms were spotless and all the amenities were taken care of. Literally the only downsides to this place were the sound of the train that goes all hours of the night and the fact that it was situated on a main thoroughfare so finding a place to go walking or running was tough unless we wanted to drive the 10 mins to the cute town of Vermillion. Very responsive host and we will definitely stay here again!

Our stay at Gilmore Manor was truly unforgettable. The house was the perfect backdrop for our French-themed girls’ weekend, and it brought us right back to our days of living together in our sorority—getting ready together, sharing stories, and laughing late into the night. Every room was filled with charm and intention. We especially loved using the beautiful dishes and cups, which made each meal feel special. The spacious dining room allowed all 13 of us to gather comfortably, creating such a warm, communal atmosphere. While the price is on the higher side, being able to split it between a group made it manageable—and honestly, you get so much in return. The care, character, and attention to detail in this home are unmatched. You can truly feel the love poured into it. It’s a magical place, and we feel so lucky to have been part of its story. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a beautiful, inspiring place to stay and connect with others.

This is a fantastic stay! Apartment is very cute and artsy. Neighborhood is safe and Location Location Location!!! Walkable to all bars, restaurants and activities we were so busy in this cute town and were able to walk our dogs plenty of places. Jessica takes great care of her space would highly recommend!!!

We loved Renee's home! It was very clean, well decorated, well furnished, well updated, and comfortable. The location was excellent as well. The home comfortably accommodated 6 adults and our 3 dogs. Most of all, Renee was a fabulous host-very friendly, responsive, kind and accommodating. As a retired Military, it was very gracious of her to offer a Military discount, which meant a lot to me.