Holiday rentals in Middlebury

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Middlebury

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Top guest favourite
A cozy cottage is depicted, featuring a welcoming front deck with seating under a shade structure. Stairs lead from the yard to the entrance. Lush greenery frames the property, and the nearby rocky pathway provides access to the water, enhancing the outdoor space.
Cottage in Middlebury
4.81 out of 5 average rating, 287 reviews

Stone Lake Cottage Middlebury IN Boat Fish getaway

Located on beautiful Stone lake in Middlebury, IN. Crafts Amish antique auction fish swim lake relaxing. Bedding, towels, and personals/toiletries are provided. 2 queens, 1 twin, 2 double beds. Includes 3 BR/4 baths (detached 3rd BR CLOSED in winter), room for 6-8, AC, Smart TV, streaming services , WiFi, fireplace, lake, pier, kayak, paddle boat, grill, fire pit, dishwasher, toys for swimming, fishing, and 5 miles from Shipshewana/Middlebury. Min primary guest age is 21. Motel hotel

Top guest favourite
The spacious living area features arched ceilings and large windows, allowing natural light to fill the room. Comfortable seating is arranged around a central coffee table, with a flat-screen TV mounted on the wall. The adjacent kitchen includes stainless steel appliances and cabinetry.
Flat in Goshen
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 895 reviews

Half-Moon Cottage

Enjoy privacy in this beautifully handcrafted cottage with arched ceilings. The cottage is 2 miles from downtown Goshen - a vibrant small town with restaurants and shops. It's 1 mile from Goshen College, 45 minutes from Notre Dame and 25 minutes from the Amish town of Shipshewana. The cottage is beside a fruit, nut and berry orchard and gardens. It's adjacent to a city bike trail that links to the Pumpkinvine nature/bike trail. It's close to a train crossing (with whistle) and a busy street.

Top guest favourite
A welcoming front porch features two rocking chairs positioned beside a small decorative table, adorned with bright pink flowers. Lush greenery is visible in nearby planters, while sunlit windows with green shutters complete the charming country setting.
Guest suite in Shipshewana
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 547 reviews

Picket Fence Farm Private Guest Retreat Suite

Stay in a 2nd story private suite in a modern farmhouse where we reside on a family farm in Amish country. Guests have the entire 2nd floor: 2 bedrooms, a private bath, and a sitting room. You can watch Amish buggies drive by while you rock on the front porch, access shared patio spaces or sit by a creek. We have cows, goats & chickens. We're in the heart of Shipshewana Amish/Mennonite community, minutes from downtown Shipshewana & all it has. An authentic, comfortable country getaway.

Top guest favourite
Farm stay in Vandalia
5 out of 5 average rating, 249 reviews

Romantic-Hot Tub-Secluded-Scenic-Creek- Wildlife

*Escape to your private couple’s retreat. *Whether sipping coffee at sunrise or star gazing, The Grain Binn is the perfect blend of rest and charm *Situated on 70 acres with flowing creek *Pickle Ball court 1 mile from Binn *Fully stocked kitchen *Fireplace *Hot tub with towels provided * Firepit with firewood *Bird feeder for Bird lovers *King size bed with quality bedding *Forgot something? Got cha *In floor heat *Snacks *Walking trails *Good WIFI *Unplug to reconnect

Guest favourite
A new hot tub is featured on a spacious deck, surrounded by natural greenery. A cozy chair sits nearby, offering a relaxing place to enjoy the peaceful outdoor setting. Sunlight creates a bright atmosphere, highlighting the tranquil environment.
Home in Middlebury
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 209 reviews

HOT TUB | Beautiful Backyard Oasis|Newly Renovated

HOT TUB! There's a brand-new hot tub on this property that is ready for unlimited fun! This fully renovated 3 bed/2 bath ranch house in the heart of Amish country is ready for you to explore the abundant activities in northern Indiana. It is the perfect place for your stay in Middlebury and Shipshewana! It's in a tranquil neighborhood and close to everything in town. Enjoy the backyard oasis for an excellent relaxing time: hot tub, seating, fire pit (firewood provided), and backyard games.

Top guest favourite
The log cabin, surrounded by snow-covered ground, features a wooden facade with a stone base. A porch with railings and steps leads to large glass doors, allowing views of the wooded area in the backdrop. A fence runs in front, adding to the secluded atmosphere.
Cabin in Goshen
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 293 reviews

Tiny home log cabin at the pines

Nurture your most important relationships at this peaceful authentic log cabin, built in 2022, set halfway in the long lane of our 18 acre property. Enjoy privacy with the massive pine trees behind you. Relax on the front porch and watch the sunset beyond the horse pasture and cornfields. The cabin boasts Wi-Fi, TV screen w options,a soaker tub, queen bed, recliners with heating feature, a full kitchen stocked with pots and pans, a washer and dryer. Everything you need for a longer stay.

Top guest favourite
A serene riverside view captures vibrant autumn foliage reflected in calm waters. Comfortable seating is arranged on a stone patio, overlooking the river, enhancing the tranquil outdoor experience. Sunlight dances on the water's surface, inviting relaxation and connection with nature.
Flat in Mishawaka
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 537 reviews

Private Entrance Guest Suite on the River

Stay in our studio apartment suite with private exterior door entrance. Hosts live in the rest of the house. From the backyard you can fish, kayak/canoe, paddle board, enjoy a bonfire, grill, and relax by the river. There's a king memory foam bed, sleeper sofa, and 49" TV. Remote work friendly with spacious workspace desk, fast WIFI, and coffee. The closet has a mini food prep area with mini fridge and microwave, and grill out on back patio. It's a quick 15 min drive to Notre Dame.

Top guest favourite
A comfortable living room is furnished with a dark sectional sofa and an ottoman. A television is positioned on a wooden stand, with a nearby door leading outside. Natural light filters in through the window, partially covered by sheer curtains. Wood flooring adds warmth to the space.
Flat in Shipshewana
4.83 out of 5 average rating, 370 reviews

Basement Apartment *conveniently near Shipshewana*

Come stay in our private-access, BASEMENT apartment, while you visit our town of Shipshewana. Our home sits in the middle of 7 acres of woods. We love it here, and we hope you do too! Our goal, as your hosts, is to provide you with a reasonably priced, cozy space, where you feel like you are visiting a friend, not staying at a high end hotel. Small touches set us apart like laundry and light breakfast/snacks provided for stays that include Sundays (coffee is ALWAYS on at this house)

Top guest favourite
Tiny home in Shipshewana
4.93 out of 5 average rating, 173 reviews

Private Lake+Fire Pit+Sauna+Kayaks | Pine & Paddle

Welcome to Pine and Paddle — the perfect place to unplug, recharge, and reconnect with nature by the lake. Unwind at this cozy lakeside tiny home, perfect for couples, friends, or solo travelers seeking peace, nature, and a hint of adventure near downtown Shipshewana. 🔥 Campfire pad w/ firewood + lake views 🛶 Kayaks + fishing poles + private dock ♨️ Wooden barrel sauna for ultimate relaxation 🌳 Private lake, beach, & outdoor games 🛏️ Sleeps 5 w/ full-size bunks + sofa bed

Top guest favourite
A cozy studio apartment features a comfortable bed with soft linens, a wooden coffee table, and a light-colored chest of drawers. Natural light filters in through a nearby window, illuminating the space. A green armchair is positioned in one corner, adding to the inviting ambiance.
Loft in Shipshewana
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 322 reviews

Hidden Country Hide-A-Way

Come relax in our cozy, modern country, studio apartment. It is  equipt with a fully stocked kitchenette, private bathroom, comfortable living space, large screen tv and office work space.  Enjoy some of the most picturesque landscape Northern Indiana has to offer.  We are just a 10 min walk from Stone Lake and have kayak rentals available upon request.  We are conveniently located 8 miles from Shipshewana and Middlebury, IN and just a 40 minute drive from Notre Dame.

Top guest favourite
The open concept basement suite features a queen-sized bed with decorative pillows and a view of the seating area equipped with a couch and coffee table. A kitchenette is visible in the background, and stairs lead to the shared entrance. Soft lighting enhances the inviting space.
Guest suite in Goshen
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 266 reviews

Lower Level Guest Suite w/ Kitchenette (2 nt min)

Best suited for travelers in town for business and sight seeing. Well suited for longer-term contract workers as well. This beautifully updated, retreat-like, basement guest suite will provide all the space and comfort you want while you visit our area. The main entrance (keyless) is a SHARED ENTRANCE to our family home, and the steps to the lower level basement are right inside the front door. The lower level is a designated space for our guests.

Top guest favourite
A cozy living area features a gray sofa and a light armchair, with bright curtains allowing natural light to filter in. A desk and chair provide a workspace, while framed artwork decorates the walls. A patterned rug adds warmth to the wooden floor.
Apartment in Goshen
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 109 reviews

Millrace Overlook

Lovely one bedroom apartment where you can relax, work, or play amidst the beautiful nature around Goshen Dam Pond and Mill Race Canal. Great birding, biking, and fishing. (Bring bikes, fishing gear, kayaks, and binoculars.) Community: Goshen College and Goshen Hospital are walking distance. Close to downtown restaurants, Janus Motorcycles, and Greencroft Communities. Notre Dame is only 45 min away. Strong, consistent WiFi for your devices. (No TV.)

Popular amenities for Middlebury holiday rentals

Quick stats about holiday rentals in Middlebury

  • Total holiday rentals

    Explore 10 holiday rentals in Middlebury

  • Nightly prices starting at

    Middlebury holiday rentals start at $116 SGD per night before taxes and fees

  • Verified guest reviews

    Over 1,100 verified reviews to help you choose

  • Family-friendly holiday rentals

    10 properties offer extra space & child-friendly amenities

  • Wifi availability

    10 of Middlebury holiday rentals include wifi access

  • Popular amenities for guests

    Guests love Kitchen, Wifi and Pool across Middlebury rentals

  • 4.9 Average rating

    Middlebury stays are highly rated by guests – averaging 4.9 out of 5!

  1. Airbnb
  2. United States
  3. Indiana
  4. Elkhart County
  5. Middlebury