Holiday rentals with a fireplace in New Buffalo

We rented this property for our family with two little children. Although a bit small , it worked well for our needs. Lovely area, with a short pleasant walk to Lake Michigan beaches. We used to live in this neighborhood so it was very nice to revisit the area.

We had a wonderful stay and will definitely be returning! The house was beautiful and extremely clean, the master bed was so comfy and the backyard was perfect for our pup to run around in. The location was also perfect and in a peaceful area, but also only about 10 minutes to New Buffalo and some amazing restaurants! I would definitely recommend and can’t wait to book our next trip back here!!

Denise was responsive, kind, and extremely helpful. Her house was immaculate, with every detail considered. Thoroughly enjoyed our time at Spyglass!

We loved staying at Katrina’s place! It was very comfortable, clean and uncluttered. We felt right at home the minute we walked through the door. New Buffalo was a short drive away so had a nice dinner at the Stray Dog. We loved spending time down at the beach and then coming home to grill some steaks. Katrina was very helpful and super communicative during our stay! Thank you for a wonderful weekend away!!

Very comfortable and lovely home to stay in. My birthday overlapped with the Indiana Migratory Bird Watching festival this year at the Dunes which was a fun way to celebrate with family and our dogs. Great home for nature lovers and birders alike. The hot tub is comfortable but if it’s windy do expect debris. Courtney was very responsive with all our hot tub needs. We used both AC and heat and both work well. Wifi is very easy to connect and troubleshoot. Very comfortable screened in porch. Overall a lovely stay and would highly recommend!!

We come to this area often to see family, often for larger gatherings, and this is the second time we spent time at Courtney & Garrett’s place - last time, other out of town family stayed here and we all had dinner at their house. The hosts were always quick to reply to our messages, and offered several suggestions for things to do and places to eat. Their place is clean with personal touches, and my favorite design mix of modern and vintage. It has newer architectural elements and appliances, along with antique/classic furniture and design pieces so it doesn’t feel sterile like you’re sitting in a showroom at a furniture store but still feels clean and modern. The house has all the things one might need, is set in a private and beautiful location & is literally surrounded by nature, viewable through tons of floor to ceiling windows. We had a lovely stay and I’m sure we’ll come back again!

This was our second time staying at Birdhaven, and it is truly one of my favorite Airbnbs. It has the look and feel of a classic Harbor Country cottage, and my family of four immediately felt at home. Highly recommend this place both for its comfort and location—it’s a short drive to Warren Dunes, and we were able to walk to the local beach every night for sunset. Just a delight.

Igor's Prairie Home was the perfect backdrop for my husband and adult children to take a break and reconnect as a family. The home is beautiful and so comfortable. We enjoyed the great hot tub and sitting around the fire pit. Oh and I don't want to forget to mention the tree house! How clever 🌞. Location is perfect for anything you'd like to do in the area because the house is located with easy access to Red Arrow highway. Either way you go there is plenty to see and do. Everyone wants to stay at Igor 's again and my son in law has already recommended to his parents. So I know we'll be back. 😎⛱️

Our group of 4 adults and 4 kids loved this place! There was plenty of space for us to spread out and relax, and also for us all to eat meals together at the big dining table. The kitchen had everything we needed, and we were never bored with all of the games, books, and puzzles in the house. The view of the beach (with snow on it!), and Chicago in the distance, was stunning. And it's just a short walk down the steps to the sand. Even in the cold weather, it is a beautiful stretch of beach. We will be back!

Lisa was an amazing host! The location was great right on the lake and the space had everything we needed. I highly recommend staying with her!

Very cute little inn. Nice to park on the premises and nice yard to sit as well as pvt hot tub. The suite was very nice and walkable down town, beach.. great having the amtrak in town and took a day trip to chicago. Definitely be back!!! Lisa has done a great job with the Inn…

Loved my stay! The farm was gorgeous and so peaceful and rejuvenating. Wish I could’ve stayed longer and would definitely stay again. Dan and Suzanne were friendly and helpful and the apartment was comfortable, well-equipped and beautifully decorated. 5 stars!

we had a great a time

We had an amazing time! Me and my boyfriend stayed for one night, the patio and dock were super cozy and we really enjoyed sitting out there at night just listening to music and having some drinks. Super nice area, the beach isn't too far and they have some fun bars and restaurants in the area. Overall, we really enjoyed our stay.

I can’t speak highly enough of Lynette and the accommodations. Lynette was a very responsive, communicative host. The extra touches she put into the stay were noticed and appreciated. The accommodations were sparkling clean, ultra comfortable and matched the listing photos and description perfectly. The property location was extremely serene. I would most definitely recommend staying here!!

Such a cute spot in a quaint little town. Apartment has everything you need and more and is conveniently located to coffee shops, restaurants, and retail. 10/10.

We had a lovely family reunion at St Joe’s overlook. Kitchen came with literally everything- all sorts of cooking instruments (crock pot, air fryer, toaster etc), spices/oils, and zip lock bags for leftovers. All brand new appliances and ample prep space. We got the pool heated and it was wonderful! Very large size to fit all the family kids. The hot tub was a nice save for the adults who were freezing. Beautiful views from the living room of the river with ample and comfy seating. The home was perfect for a large gathering. We appreciate Evan and Claire hosting us they were always responsive and helpful.

Home is gorgeous and updated. Thoughtfully stocked towels and linens. Beautiful surroundings- we very much enjoyed watching the sunset from the private hot tub! Would love to travel here again!

Bruce & Carol were excellent hosts anticipating needs while going above and beyond to make the stay special. The home has beautiful landscaping and gardens. Plenty of room for children to run and play. The breeze from the lake can be enjoyed throughout the home. The house has lake front views throughout the main rooms. The home is positioned ideally for guests with 3 separate living spaces and an open kitchen to the main gathering space that opens to the deck and grill. The walk to St. Joseph is less than a mile and we completed this enjoyable walk daily. Farmer market operates every Saturday during the summer with concerts on Sunday evenings all in walking distance of home. The private beach is beautiful and hosts shared paddle boards and beach toys to add to experience. We enjoyed sunset walks to the lighthouse pier. The internet is fast and reliable for those looking to work away from home with 2-3 possible office locations in home. We would return here again.

Kawal is an amazing host! The house is absolutely beautiful and aptly named. My family had a wonderful time and Kawal did everything he could and more to make our stay incredible. I’ve already told him, but I will say it again….thank you Kawal for making our time magnificent!