Pet-friendly holiday rentals in New Buffalo Township

How can I put in a few words how we felt about Cary’s house! We loved it immediately, everything outside, everything inside! Absolutely NOTHING was missing. Anything you needed was waited for you to need it. The house is meant to please the pickiest folks . You can’t name a thing that was a disappointment. Where else will you find a garden just waiting for you to pick it??

What a wonderful stay our family had in Michiana Shores, Indiana at Greg’s place. Even though 2 of the 3 days were mostly overcast / rain, there was still plenty of activities to do. We hung out in the pool & hot tub areas multiple times, had a fire every night, and cooked all 3 meals each day in the wonderfully maintained kitchen. The kids loved their room setup with the bunk bed and twin bed. The parks nearby are lovely. The backyard was very luscious with tranquility full of greenery and peacefulness. Greg was very responsive and helped us out with questions before and during our stay. Definitely would recommend this spot if you are wanting to take a vacation near the nationally known Indiana Sand Dunes. Overall 5+ stars!

This is a second wonderful stay that I had at Diane's place. Would highly recommend to those visiting the Berrien Springs area.

Very clean house, very close to the beach. Has everything you need for a short visit. We packed 7 people in without feeling too cramped.

Beautiful historic home in a wonderful area! Easy walk to the beach, shops, and restaurants!

We were very pleased with our stay. From the lovely landscaping and cool firepit area to the pristine interior, the host had paid attention to every detail in accommodating the comfort of his guests. The fully stocked coffee bar and spacious dining area overlook the deck, back yard, and beautiful woods beyond the yard. The dining area adjoins a cozy fireplace area with seating to enjoy your after meal beverages. There is also a living room with large TV. The spacious master bedroom is extremely comfortable with quality bedding, high ceiling fans, and plenty of drawers to store luggage items. The bathrooms are large and spotless. The kitchen is fully equipped. We enjoyed the convenience to area shops, restaurants, and pints of interest. The rural, wooded area is very relaxing. You are sure to enjoy your stay in this lovely place.

Our family had an amazing stay here! The design of the home was incredible and it was a great location. Our kids are already asking when we can come back! The close proximity to the beach was amazing. What a beautiful place!

We had a wonderful stay in town for a wedding at Journeyman. Location is perfect, lots to walk to. It was so nice to be able to bring our dogs with us. House was stocked with everything we could have needed (including a coffee grinder!). Highly recommend!

Wish there were a few games/books/activies in the unit other than that great place clean and modern.

Absolutely adorable, peaceful, and amazing location! The camper was super clean!!! The staff are all friendly! It had everything you could possibly need in it too! Heater, fan, coffee press, a/c, hair dryer, even fresh cut flowers! It had literally everything!!! The heated pool was absolutely phenomenal! The hiking trails were amazing too! It was such a peaceful get away! We enjoyed hiking the trails with our dog, swimming, and playing games while looking at the beautiful scenery around us! Can’t wait to go back again!!!!

We had a great stay! The house was perfect. It was nice and clean with a great rooftop deck and screened in porch. The location could not have been better, walking distance to everything in town. Everything was easy as far as check in and check out with a book explaining everything in the house. Mark was great at responding to questions. I would highly recommend staying here.

Loved our stay! The house was very nice and clean

Amazing trip for our family. The home was clean, beautiful and the location was wonderful with walkable restaurants and places to get coffee, groceries. The pool was perfect for our kids. We felt right at home :) Our host was great and extremely responsive to any messages. Looking forward to a future trip.

The house was amazing! My family ended up taking pictures of the decor as inspiration for their own houses! The host was absolutely wonderful, the pool was amazing, and the house was perfect! Oh! And something else to acknowledge is how comfortable the beds were…! You definitely don’t get that many places! So glad we stayed here :)

We had a lovely family reunion at St Joe’s overlook. Kitchen came with literally everything- all sorts of cooking instruments (crock pot, air fryer, toaster etc), spices/oils, and zip lock bags for leftovers. All brand new appliances and ample prep space. We got the pool heated and it was wonderful! Very large size to fit all the family kids. The hot tub was a nice save for the adults who were freezing. Beautiful views from the living room of the river with ample and comfy seating. The home was perfect for a large gathering. We appreciate Evan and Claire hosting us they were always responsive and helpful.

We had an absolutely amazing stay at this beautifully decorated and incredibly comfortable home. From the moment we arrived, we felt right at home — every detail was thoughtfully designed, creating a warm and inviting atmosphere. The space was spotless, stylish, and perfectly equipped for a relaxing getaway. One of the highlights of our experience was the exceptional management team. They were extremely kind, friendly, and responsive, making everything seamless from check-in to check-out. It’s rare to find such genuine hospitality!

Awesome house, I stayed here for a girls weekend and we just loved the space and view of the water. Tons to do in New Buffalo, and the house was so close to the main area of town.

Very nice home and surrounding area, and very active community. The loft is fun for kids. The host reached out daily. Easy walk to the beach with our dog. The boat rental w/ captain was fun, and got a little tour of the shoreline. Awesome quality of food at the local restaurants!

Third time staying here - we love this place. Brendon and Bryndal do an amazing job communicating and their place is always clean and in great shape. We like the walking areas near the house for our pup and the disc golf in Michigan City. Always a pleasure to visit - thanks

Really comfortable beds and quiet space to be!

We really enjoyed staying here. It’s close to many things, and very peaceful and quiet. A beautiful and relaxing place to stay.

My wife, our dog and I stayed at the farmhouse for a long weekend to relax away from the city. It was the perfect country escape- peaceful, tranquil and still a quick drive to everything we wanted to explore. We mostly went to New Buffalo for restaurants and kayaking, and to the Indiana Dunes for hiking. The farmhouse was tastefully decorated with upscale amenities (like the coffee maker we decided to purchase when we got home). Mornings were spent reading on the screened in porch, listening to the birds and watching the chickens outside. There’s plenty of seating if you have a larger group, with tables inside and outside for meals. Stefanie was a wonderful host, her guidebook has great recommendations of things to do in the area and she gave very helpful instructions for the house. We definitely hope to return sometime as it’s so close to Chicago! Perfect weekend trip.

Sarah's place was perfect for our weekend trip. It was so nice, cozy, clean and very well decorated. The area itself is so green and beautiful and this spot was a great location for exploring beaches, Union Pier, New Buffalo and surrounding quaint and charming towns! We will absolutely be coming back!

Jill’s place was lovely. Very nicely nestled into a cozy community. Close to Indiana Dunes and Michigan beaches. Would definitely stay again.