Cottage holiday rentals in Sunset Bay

This was a phenomenal stay! The house was clean and well stocked (e.g. toilet paper, soap, dishes, etc.). The rooms were as posted in the photos, so there were no surprises! Vu was a very responsive and helpful host. When we had trouble with the hot tub, he came down right away and checked the water for us. As a suggestion for those visiting, if you are sensitive to pool chemicals, you should run the hot tub for one cycle before getting in. There were some spatulas that were unclean in the drawer, but this was not of big concern to us as it might have just been missed while cleaning. Location wise, it’s walkable to Crystal Beach and it has some cute shops along the way! Overall, we would definitely stay here again!

The place was incredibly accommodating for the group of 8 of us !! We had a great time hanging out in the backyard and between the kitchen and dining table with the open concept. The place was tidy, clean, and all the amenities were as advertised — would definitely stay again!

Kelly's cottage was perfect for me and my boys to get away! The stream behind the house was lovely and just a short paddle to Chautauqua Lake. My kids loved the hot tub! The cottage was fully stocked with dishes to cook with and coffee and snacks (my boys loved the mini popcorn!), as well as, plenty of fresh linens and towels. We had such a great time and are looking forward to making this a yearly tradition already!

Lennie's place is an absolute Jem. The place is fabulous, with breathtaking lake and beach views from almost anywhere in the house. The deck is such an oasis and literally a few steps away from the amazing Wyldewood beach. One of the best beaches I've been in the area, with amazing amenities within the premises. From groceries shop, great selection of food trucks, onsite restaurant, bar, arcade, watrepark, mini golf and a long etc. Lenni keeps the place prestine and super equipped with anything you could possible need to make your stay comfortable. A highlight was the private golf cart. This made our stay not only super convenient but very fun to move around and explore all the great things the premises have to offer. Communication with Lennie was outstanding! She was super quick to reply, always willing to address all my questions and proactively providing guidance on how to move around, and make good use of the house and entire premises. I can't wait to come back!!!

Mandy’s place and Sherkston Shores are amazing! Mandy was so responsive and made everything easy about our stay! The cottage is beautiful, steps from the beach, and has everything you’d ever need! We will be back!

The home is so beautiful, I took pictures because I really want to build a home and it’s what I’m going to base it off of!!! Kathlene was so helpful. Anything we needed she was right on it.!! we will plan on coming again in the future! You will not be disappointed in this location or the home itself!!

Our stay at Lauren’s in Sherkston Shores was absolutely fantastic! The cottage was clean, cozy, and perfectly equipped with everything we needed for a comfortable and relaxing vacation. It truly felt like a home away from home. The location was perfect for our family. The hosts are very friendly, responsive, and made sure everything was smooth from check-in to check-out. You can tell they really care about providing a great experience for their guests. Whether you're traveling with family, friends, or just looking for a peaceful escape, this is a spot we highly recommend. We’re already looking forward to booking our next trip for 2026 here. Stephanie & Family

Paul is a great host. Very knowledgeable & helpful. Walked us through house instructions clearly. The cottage is great, ambience is magnificent and everything is just a 5 to 10 mins walk away or even better, charge & take the golf cart! It’s a nice ride to the beach or to the soccer field where most of the evening events occur. Definitely coming back to this place.

Absolutely loved our stay at this Airbnb! From the moment we arrived, the host made us feel incredibly welcome. The space was impeccably clean, beautifully decorated, and had all the amenities we needed for a comfortable stay. The location was perfect—close to the water. We especially enjoyed our morning walks around the area and looking at all the homes and our dog especially loved running on the small beach area. Beach is Dog friendly till 10am and after 5pm. Every detail was taken care of, making our stay truly memorable. Highly recommend this place for anyone looking for a wonderful getaway! Would definitely stay here again! 🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 Ps… thank you for the beach chairs!!!

WOW! That’s what we said when we opened the front door. The view of the lake was awesome and Barbara’s house was perfect for the 4 of us celebrating our 70th birthdays. We have stayed in many Airbnb’s before but this house had every amenity you could ask for. It is tastefully decorated and well stocked including paper products, shampoos, spices, etc. The beds were very comfortable and the view of the morning sunrise from the master bedroom was absolutely breathtaking! We visited the National Comedy Museum in Jamestown and walked the beautiful grounds of the Chautauqua Institute ! Barbara was the perfect hostess and even offered to mail the clothes we left in the dryer back to us. As one ages, we tend to remember the “moments” and forget the “things”🥴. Thank you, Barbara, for transforming your shack into a spectacular cottage and sharing it with us.

The Crystal Cottage is such an amazing place! Anne Marie and Norm are such wonderful hosts and go out of their way to make guests feel comfortable. The cottage is in a great location within walking distance to everything and is still very quiet an peaceful. The local people are also fantastic and make guests feel welcome. I highly recommend the Crystal Cottage to other guests and will be back for sure!

This place was everything we had hoped it would be , it was so clean and beautiful. We made alot of beautiful memories that we will treasure for a lifetime. The host was very responsive and helpful.. I would come back again and I will be telling everyone about this place

Very nice house close to the shoreline - beautiful sunrises!

A great couple of days! From the phone call a couple of days, Jeff was proactive to ensure we had a wonderful stay. Very well situated - easy walk to restaurants and the beach as well as to access the Friendship Trail for biking. Comfortable beds too. Slept great. Thanks, Jeff!

I was looking for a last-minute getaway from Toronto with my dog Luna, and Robert was quick to respond and accommodate us. The Airbnb is the perfect cottage -- cozy, thoughtfully decorated, and equipped with everything we needed for a relaxing stay. Every detail made it feel warm and welcoming. We enjoyed peaceful walks on the beach and also discovered a lovely trail nearby for Luna to explore. When I accidentally locked myself out of the cottage, Robert was incredibly responsive and showed up within 10 minutes to let us back in. We’re already planning our next trip back — we highly recommend staying at Robert and Cole's!

What a wonderful cozy cottage just a few steps from long beach. We stayed for a few days in October and it was a perfect time of the year for a peaceful getaway. The cottage was very clean and equipped with everything you could need. We enjoyed the sunroom and our dogs found it to be a good spot to nap. Sarah was a an excellent host and we will be sure to come back for a longer stay next time.

We loved our stay! The house is absolutely beautiful and looks even better than the pictures. The location is ideal because you are right on the beach and you can easily walk into town which we took advantage of. Our family of 5 (3 young children) had the best time. We have already booked another stay for 2026. Coco was extremely responsive and answered any questions I had within minutes. Book! You will not be disappointed!

Charming, updated older beach cottage. Really enjoyed the place. Family of six adults was very comfortable. Only thing we missed were sharp knives and oven mitts. Everything else in the kitchen was equipped so we could cook meals. Very pretty Lake view. Very small towns and not much else to do. We spent our time in Niagara Falls and Niagara on the lakes. Great homebase, though if you want a relaxing Lakeside retreat. Really appreciated the cozy blankets and space heaters. Beds and pillows comfortable.

My inlaws and I had a great 3 night stay at this location! We visited the local wineries and Niagara falls! Perfect location, and a beautiful outdoor area and plenty of room for us 4. We got to see hummingbirds from the deck too!

Amazing stay for 3 months for 5-6 people, spacious and private, quiet, and peaceful. Everyone can find a personal spot. Really enjoyable place even for people with a different mindset. The host's choice of coffee was beautiful.

This lovely cottage was full of thoughtful touches. The bed was comfortable, the kitchen well appointed and the living area spacious. The location is peaceful and yet lively restaurants and the beach are only a 10 minute walk away. I especially appreciated being a little away from the beach on an extremely busy long weekend. This is perfect place to stay for a summer cottage getaway in Crystal Beach.

The cottage was perfect for us! It is just like the pictures and Stephen and Chelsea were very responsive. I also want to mention how family friendly the cottage is. We have a 3 and 1 yr old and the cottage had baby gates upstairs and downstairs, an adorable play kitchen set that kept them very entertained, pack and play, high chair and more. We really appreciated all the extras for the kiddos - thanks so much!

We had such a great time. Hai was so easy to communicate with. Her place is spotless and the pictures do not do it justice. Thank you so much!!!

We absolutely loved our time at Anu’s lakeside cottage. We felt right at home. The lake was gorgeous and sounded like the ocean. The waves never stopped and the wind kept the bugs away. We enjoyed our evenings around the fire and bbq’d every night. The stars didn’t disappoint, there was very little light pollution! Oh and the sunsets were amazing. The cottage was homey, yet spacious and very comfortable. We slept so well, and it was great having a spare room for the two pack’n plays for our twins. It was our first getaway as a family of four and we hope to book there again next year!