Find Places to Stay in Fire Island on Airbnb

Had an awesome experience. All I needed was available. The place was clean and neat. The hosts Jeff and I'm sorry i can't remember the other guy's name were awesome, helpful, sweet and accommodating. Will definitely come back and stay here.

Great place! Double bed is a bit small for two adults. Otherwise excellent experience.

Wonderful experience! Will certainly return.

Very pleasant little condo complex right in the heart of Ocean Bay Park. A good mix of people - groups of friends, some families - and inviting public areas where people were hanging out, sharing food, enjoying themselves, etc. Onsite manager, Jeff, was very friendly and involved. Recommended.

This condo is absolutely perfect for a Fire Island getaway! They had towels, chairs, an umbrella, toiletries, etc. Jeff is super hospitable and helpful. We can't wait to stay again!

Jeff was amazing, the place is everything you'd wish for in a perfect visit to Fire Island!

My first AirBnB stay may have spoiled me for future trips. Robby and Joe really lived up to our extremely high expectations. (And then some! I wasn't expecting the gift basket!) The interior of the house is really lovely, and the three bathrooms made it easy to share with the wedding guests who stayed with us. Within hours, the house felt like home. We made abundant use of the kitchen and its spanking new appliances; I covet that dishwasher. The view of the bay from the deck is as good as it gets, from sunrise to sunset to starlight.

SUPER HOSTS..... Amazing Home, Location, All the Amenities you need in every room. They checked in during our stay to make sure we were comfortable, etc.

This was a wonderful experience. Great and kind community. Clean and organized place. Thank you so much

Fantastic home and great place for a getaway. Thanks to Robby and Joe for being amazing hosts.

The deck and view of the bay is honestly enough to make this the perfect spot. But the house was absolutely perfect. It's not even 2 minutes from "town" but still very quiet. Three bedrooms, three bathrooms, all new and beautifully kept. The living area is open and gets amazing light. Clean, comfortable, it is the perfect spot for a Cherry Grove getaway. Robby and Joe were incredible hosts, there were super quick and responsive leading up to the trip, they left a very sweet welcome basket for us on the dining room table, and Joe met us at the ferry when we arrived to take us to the house, show us around and how everything worked, and made sure we had everything you need.

Where do I start... My wife-Eli and I came in late in the evening and also had to leave a day early so, unfortunately, we did not get to meet Robby and Joe in person. Super sad about this bc I really enjoyed them over text. We rented the house with 2 of our friends who got to meet Joe upon check-in. I was told he was very welcoming and accommodating! Even though we didn’t get to meet, I had the very same impression via text from both of them! The place was as perfect as we expected. Super clean, great taste and very organized- InstaLove! The house had everything we needed. Every room in the entire house, including the deck, had amazing energy! Eli and I are very picky with the places we stay in. This place definitely lived up to our expectations and more! Our favorite is having a serene breakfast with a view... this house gave us exactly that! :) Robby and Joe know how to treat their guests, they checked in with us once we got settled to see if everything was okay and then let us have our space the rest of the time. It’s no surprise that Robby and Joe are SuperHosts! I definitely plan to recommend their vacation home to everyone!!!

LOVED this space!! The space alone is to die for and once you step in, you will go into zen mode automatically. As if that weren't enough, Robby met us with open arms and a big smile to welcome us. Not to mention a very thoughtful basket of goodies that just added an extra special touch to make us feel welcome. I'm already trying to plan my next stay!!!

Its doesn't get better than this! Robby and Joe were so communicative and thought of everything and more. The house is ever more beautiful than the pictures display, the location is perfect and you'll feel at home the moment you walk in. The only downside is you'll never want to leave! Can't thank the guys enough for their hospitality and we'll be back for sure!

The space is as advertised - it is modern, clean and Petra’s hospitality is second only to her generosity. Check in was an absolute breeze (thank you for the cart, that was super helpful!) and I highly recommend Dune Point.

We had a great stay in this space. Modern and cozy, super well-thought out and close to a fantastic beach front. Ramon was right there for us and the whole experience of doing a little exploring on the island was comfortable and fun. I'd love to come back and stay here again!

I’d recommend this space to anyone and everyone. The private deck is amazing, it’s stylish and super clean, and you’re close to everything — especially the beach which is just a few steps away. Loved it!

The studio apartment was perfect for our weekend trip to Fire Island. It’s close to the beach, restaurants, and bars, but far enough removed from it all so that you don’t have to hear it. Walls are really really thin, so if you are a light sleeper, bring earplugs. We had a really lovely time and I’d highly recommend staying there.

A clean and comfortable guesthouse just a short walk from the beach and everything else in Cherry Grove. Very friendly and helpful staff

this was our second time staying here, the location is great, only steps from everything including the beach.

I loved staying at this property. It has just enough space to relax/cook/etc. and has a great patio. Steps away from the beach. It is my 2nd time staying at Petra’s and won’t be the last. Thank you!

Perfect in every way !!!!

John and Ben’s place is a dream! My friend and I had the most relaxing few days there, and John and Ben were wonderful hosts. Would absolutely stay there again.

Jon and Ben are fantastic hosts - very personable and welcoming. The location is on the quieter side of pines so perfect for me. Watching sunset on the deck is amazing. The checkout time is until 2 pm which is really considerate given it is the best time of the day - they actually allowed me to stay longer because I missed my ferry. Very good experience overall.

John & Ben's place on Fire Island is wonderfully accommodating, with easy access to the Pines harbor, to Cherry Grove, to the beach, and with a pool. John & Ben were also flexible, considerate, and generous hosts, who were very helpful and fun to socialize with. I would eagerly book with them again. Merci John & Ben!

They were great people to stay with

John & Ben were very accommodating and answered any questions we had in a timely manner. The house was beautiful with great views and had everything we needed and more -- the pizza pool float was a big hit. Would absolutely come back.

John O. was a great host. He was informative and responsive before and during our stay. The photos and description of the listing were accurate. My friends and I had a wonderful time!

everything was pretty perfect. John in particular was both professional (with regard to details & clarity) and gracious (with regard to welcome & ongoing communications), even though he wasn't on the same continent.

First time visiting Cherry Grove and the place was exactly what I was expecting. Clean, close to the beach, full kitchen and more. We will certainly return.

This is our second Time staying and I’m glad it was another great stay with hospitality. Pablo was nice to open our door late at night since we Locked ourselves out.

Dune Point has been the only place I've stayed while in cherry grove! although i was disappointed not to be able to book ocean front accommodations, i was happy to be on fire island, and have access to the beach, close to my apartment. this was a girls trip, my friend and i had an amazing time! the party starts on the ferry, right!! If you get a chance to see hedda lettuce at cherry GOOOOO! this chelsea girl is the best!

We had an amazing time! The place is wonderful!

Beautiful little one bedroom. Modern and stylist. Perfect for a short trip to Cherry Grove.

Wonderful space for such a unique part of the world. It was our home away from home.

We liked this spot so much we returned a year later! Great hosts who were responsive and accommodating to our needs. Very relaxing getaway.

Dune Point is a lovely hotel in Cherry Grove on Fire Island which my husband and I have stayed in several times. Hosts Petra and Ramon are friendly and accommodating. Fire Island is, of course, sheer heaven.

Our whole family loved spending five days at this true beach cottage. It’s in a perfect location and we enjoy the less fancy/more rustic & homey feel. Can’t wait to go back!! Brent is a wonderful host.

We had a fantastic time. The location is perfect and the pool deck is great for hanging out with a group.

We had a great time. The location was amazing. You could literally access the beach from the front door. The pool, hot tub and deck area were perfect for hosting our group of friends. The outdoor shower next to the pool was very convenient.

The location right on the beach makes for a really fun and relaxing vacation. Much of our time was spent at the pool or at the beach. The house has three bedrooms as well as a pull out bed so you can really fit a good number of people there, and the walk to the Pines is really easy day or night. Makes for a really relaxing and fun vacation. Our cell phones didn't work this far out, which we treated as a blessing. There is Wifi in the house though if you really need it.

Stephen was responsive and kind and the house is amazing — pool, hot tub, outdoor shower, and laundry, and it’s one house into the bay side of the island. Will book again for sure.

The house is everything one needs for a fabulous week in gay heaven. The design of the home naturally brings people together into the common spaces and around the pool. The house is very conveniently located across from Whyte Hall and is just a quick twirl away from the harbor and Cherry Grove. Definitely a great value for the experience! And Stephen is wonderful too! All around win.

583 Seaview is an amazing FIP house for a great price and Stephen is a fantastic host! Everything about the house was exactly as described. The layout is great - the large foyer on the ground floor gives a lot of breathing room for the bedrooms/private baths, and the open floor plan on the second floor is comprised of 5 large, updated living spaces -- TWO living rooms, dining room with table that seats 10, kitchen, balcony and entryway, plus a FIFTH large bathroom, and a pantry with a SECOND fridge! House feels very spacious for 8 people. And has an emergency drag chest that could dress 10! And that DECK. The huge pool and deck are really among the best in the Pines. New hot tub and wet bar with tasteful lighting really make for a special space. Stephen was a lovely host and very responsive. The pilot light for one of the hot water heaters went out on our second day, and Stephen had a repair person at the house within the hour to fix it. He checked in throughout our week-long stay, even sharing some fun stories about the house. Who would have guessed that Liza Minnelli and Debbie Reynolds have stayed there?!

We came to Fire Island on the off season so the location was great and there were no other people around. Close to the Marina and very close to the beach. A lot of space and each downstairs bedroom has it's own bathroom.

This house looks even better in person. The layout (common area on top, sleeping space on the bottom) works so well. The house is far enough away from the harbor to feel secluded, but close enough that the walk into town is manageable. Stephen is a fantastic, responsive host. All our questions were quickly addressed and the entire process was stress-free.

Great House. Plenty of space and a great pool/jacuzzi. Highly recommend trying it out!

Terrific stay! Cozy, clean, comfortable, thoughtful details through out. Well appointed kitchen, nice deck with grill, great outdoor shower! Exactly what we were looking for.

Our stay at the Papa’s was great! The listing was accurately portrayed online, and the location was even better than we anticipated. Far enough away from the hustle and bustle, but close enough for a short walk to everything. The outdoor shower was great (as many other reviews pointed out) and the beach supplies and washer/dryer were super helpful. Great trip overall!

This was the perfect place for a couple and a small dog to spend the week at! Close to the beach and to restaurants but far enough away to feel totally separate and peaceful. Great outdoor space and outdoor shower, plus beach chairs included 👍

My family has stayed at The Mamas/The Papas a few times over the years, and our stays have always been relaxing. This time we stayed at The Papas. The homes are lovely, very well kept, conveniently close to the beach, stores and restaurants. Rod is a great host always available for questions and is accommodating.

Great location in Cherry Grove, completely private space with beautiful view of sunsets from main window. Ideal for single traveler or couple. Air conditioner worked great on sweltering days. Full sized washer dryer made for easy packing. Bathroom bit tiny but outdoor shower is a cool experience. Close to restaurants and bars but quiet at night. Easy access to Pines. Host very responsive and checking in a breeze. Definitely recommend for area and easily beats sharing a room with a stranger, which can be common experience when using Airbnb to secure lodging on Fire Island.

Very nice place and in a great location!

What can I say this place has an excellent location. It is very nicely and pointed, with artistic and cute vintage touches. The outdoor shower was amazing. I highly recommend.

Incredibly cozy studio apartment in a perfect location in Cherry Grove! Close to the beach, close to the bars, and easily accessible to other parts of the island. Fell in love with the shower outside as well, never showered inside once!

Amazingly helpful and responsive hosts. Check in could not be any easier! Petra has copies of her hand drawn map of Cherry Grove and shows you everything you need to know. Mika was super helpful with find a solution for our bags on the last day. The place itself was sparkling clean and very cute. Location? You already know!

We had a great time at Cherry Grove and staying at Dune Point was perfect for us. The bungalow was super clean and like new. It was efficient and all we needed to cook, shower and sleep. We like quiet evenings when we visit Cherry Grove and this studio was ideal. Also a very short walk to the beach and to town. Everyone working at Dune Point was super sweet, friendly, communicative and helpful. Ramon let us store our luggage after check out so we can enjoy the beaches for another afternoon before departing the island. We definitely would recommend this very professional and easy rental experience to anyone.

Love cherry grove and this is a great spot to stay. We were able to check in early. We were asked daily if we needed anything. Place was very clean and well appointed. Can’t wait to go back!

Close to the heart of Fire Pines. Easy access to the beach. Great person with whom to work.

Apartment is in a great location, close to the ferry and the beach. The place is spotless. It has a kitchen if you want to cook and even has a grill. I highly recommend this place!

The apartment is simple and elegant and great for a single or a couple. the location is great: close to town/ferry but also feels private and out of the way. steps to the beach. Jaime is graciously dog (and human) friendly, and couldn't have been more attentive and welcoming.

Jaimie was a great host! Very cute, clean appartment with great amenities and access to all things in the town as well as the beach.

Great location! Steps away from the beach AND the harbor. Refreshing pool, nice deck w a hot tub and Jaime’s hospitality exceeded our expectations. Thanks again Jaime

This apartment is an exceptionally well located unit in a beautiful and stylish home.

Lovely spacious, stylish independent apartment with its own entrance and all the necessary amenities. There is a washer and a dryer so you can pack less clothes. The apartment was super clean. The location is great just a few steps away from the ocean but also close to the port. Jaime has been amazing. We are definitely going back.

Jaime is kind and thoughtful with a beautiful home in fire island pines. I would love to stay here again. Great attention to detail and comfortable apartment to rent.

Georgie was very on point with communication

A good place

Nice little place to eat and sleep in

Great host, very responsive and responsible. Great location and a great neighborhood, close to amazing restaurants and the beaches. The studio is very private and has everything you need. Highly recommended for an extended stay.

It has been an absolute pleasure staying at this location. George is a very accommodating host and his mother is delightful, too. The apartment was clean and in the perfect location for our needs. We would definitely stay at this listing again in the future.

Nothing but great things to say. Excellent location, very private! Parking spot is right up front. Host (Georgie) was very easy to talk to and laid back. Would definitely stay again. 10/10!

Great spot!

Georgie was an amazing host. He was extremely helpful. The place was nice and clean. We will be back.

We had a fantastic stay! This is the perfect place to stay in Ocean Beach! It is a short walk from the ferry and the town as well it is a quick walk to the beach. The home was nicely decorated and really makes you feel like you are at the beach. I have stayed at many other houses in fire island and many had very small rooms but this house was perfect for my group of 8 people. Everyone had privacy in the spacious 4 bedrooms and the home is well equipped with a fully stocked kitchen and the deck was a great place to relax and grill up some steaks. The foosball table was a real treat and the Wifi was faster than my Wifi at home. The host Ben was super responsive and really helped to make sure our stay at his home was a pleasure! We can't wait to come back next season and would definitely recommend staying here!

This place was great for my big group! The living room was big enough for is to comfortably hang out and the kitchen and outdoor tables fit us all for lovely meal experiences. The location can’t be beat!

Great place to stay for the weekend! Plenty of space for a group, nice outdoor area, two bathrooms (plus outdoor shower) was very helpful with a larger group size. Close to dock, bars, beach - even had beach chairs & an umbrella we could use! The host was also very helpful in assisting when we had issues with the grill - he then assessed the situation & got us a new grill for the weekend! He was responsive and helpful. Definitely a great spot to rent on Fire Island!

Excellent!

We did a group rental for 9 days and the house was perfect. It definitely isn’t a huge, stylish place- but you quickly learn that the best part of Fire Island is that it’s all very casual and beachy! We had an amazing time and the house was conveniently located 1 block from the ferry/ town and 1 block from the beach. Benjamin was a great host and was super attentive and helpful anytime we had issues or needed recommendations. Thanks for a great stay!

A very clean place that was close to the beach and to downtown.

Perfect location for access to the beach and town.

Great place to stay in Ocean Beach. Short walk to restaurants and beach. The host was very helpful and quick to respond to all of our questions. Place is clean and new. Definitely a great place to stay in Ocean Beach

Robert’s place was a gorgeous getaway. The space was wonderfully homey, beautifully curated and really made us feel at ease. He’s was very communicative and accommodating during our stay.

I really loved staying at Roberts place! Perfect little getaway on the beach. The indoor fireplace was a nice touch in the cooler month. I will definitely be staying here again! Such a cute place.

This place is very magical. It looks just like the photos. The outdoor space is incredibly vast and we especially loved the outdoor shower. While we visited in the fall (so not prime beach time) I still really appreciated all of the thoughtful beach touches like chairs, towels, and a beach bag. Highly recommend!

This is our third time at Robert’s and we always enjoy the peace and quiet and disconnection that the house brings...even though it’s just minutes away from every happening on the Pines. It’s a beautiful quaint home and we appreciated the new additions (smart tv, electric grill, new beach chairs etc). Will def return for a fourth year!

Robert's cottage is a most relaxing and enchanting retreat. Lovely and practical touches abound, both inside and out. The living room is comfy enough for reading a book, taking a nap, binge watching your favorite series, or listening to music. The dining room and kitchen are well stocked with candles, games, utensils, appliances, and lanterns. The bedroom is very cozy, with a door to the deck, open, screened windows, books, fans and an excellent bed. Even the bathroom is lovely and spacious. Outdoors, the array of decks is impressive, with our favorite, the roof deck providing a peek at the ocean and a lovely treetop view. Each space has its virtues, with ample deck chairs throughout. There's even a tiny private beach garden, our favorite place to commune with nature, with or without a glass of wine! But when you want the ocean beach, you're less than 5 minutes away. The cottage is a 10 minute walk to the ferry and a 15 minute walk to Cherry Grove. While we've fallen in love with many beach homes over the years, we've never found a place before with equal doses of charming, relaxing, private and fun all rolled into one.

This was our second time at the cottage and we cannot wait for our third time and more. This is a very unique magical place. Thank you so much Robert!

Rustic and well loved sweet beach shack steps from the Ocean. Has everything you could need plus 4 outdoor spaces. Best for one or two people. ENJOY!

A beautiful house in a beautiful location. A real historical treat! We spent a few days on the island over a beautiful, warm August weekend and this house was the perfect setting. Robert is a brilliant host and was so kind and attentive. Couldn't recommend enough!

Super comfortable, pleasingly designed, kid friendly, convenient to everything... Perfect for families

My family had a great long weekend stay at this house in Ocean Beach. The house is very nice and comfortable with a great kitchen, living space and plenty of sleeping room. The best part is the outside area which is the biggest deck I have ever seen basically covering the entire backyard property. A huge table outside to sit at and plenty of lounging and relaxing space around the pool and the deck with shade with lounge chairs and an outdoor sofa. We were there with my parents, brothers family (including 3 kids under 5) and my family also with a toddler. It was great for everyone of all ages. The kids especially loved to pool with all of the fun pool floats that were there. And of course it is very close to the beach which is why everyone goes to fire island in the first place. There was a great wagon at the house for transporting our stuff (and kids) to the beach or to town. We also used 2 of the bikes which worked great. We made our plans to rent the place last minute because we we kept watching the weather, and the owner was very accommodating and helpful when I contacted her about renting it on short notice. We did have a problem with the pool heater not working while we were there which was disappointing, but the owner called the repair people right away, They were not able to come until Monday which was the day we left but we were only there for the weekend so hopefully we will get to enjoy that next time. We definitely plan on returning to this house for another family vacation in the future.

Great, quiet spot and a gorgeous house!!

Good quality and great location. Very much enjoyed the experience and hope to be back.

Quiet and lovely cottage. With a good situation. Dale is a charming host.

Hansel is a beautiful house in a great location. The back deck with the lounge chairs and tables is a beautiful place to spend the day, and cook out in the evenings—it's sunny and private. The house is really comfortable, so much personality in all the decor, and the location near the beach is great. We were especially happy with the well-equipped kitchen, which went beyond the usual AirBNB basics and had everything we could have needed. (There are even some yoga mats, we loved doing some yoga in the morning to the sound of the ocean.)

Charming cottage in Cherry Grove with nice amenities and very responsive host and just steps from the beach!!

hansel is a beautiful home, steps away from the beach. we had a glorious week there. it feels very much like a home that has been loved in.

The house was so cute. It was the perfect size for our group. We could see the ocean from our window and the town was just a few minutes away! The living space was very clean and welcoming and the bedrooms were both warm and cozy. We had a really great time staying at Darren & Tommy’s!

Darren & Tommy’s house was a great getaway for my family. It is very convenient to the beach and restaurants in town. It had all the basic amenities we needed for our beach weekend and we had an amazing time!

Amazing house with a gorgeous view and plenty of sleeping space. Tommy was very friendly, responsive, and helpful

Awesome location! A charming cottage with an amazing view. The listing is accurate except that it understates the view. The cottage is clean and inviting. The hosts communicate effectively and were very helpful. The place is a value compared to the prices of others with a similar view.

Great place, great location! Can't wait to come back

Perfect cottage right by the beach. Great location. Very cool entrance. Everything exceeded expectations

Amazing house, definitely coming back ❤️

This place was amazing!

Laura's place is a dream. It is exactly what we were hoping for. Perfect location, perfect vibe, all the conveniences we needed. Really a special place. And Laura is a terrific host! Easy communication and easy to check in and out. We are so grateful for the long weekend there!

This is a perfect beach bungalow for a relaxing Fire Island retreat. It has a great cottage vibe and I t is in a great location, just a short walk to the ocean and bay beaches and also close to ferry docks. The house looks just like the pictures, neat and tidy throughout with a renovated bath inside and nice roomy outdoor shower on the deck and nice deck furniture and bicycles as well. The upstairs was larger than we expected and can sleep 3 additional people. Kitchen also well stocked. We definitely hope to return and loved working with Laura.

Great location close to bay and ocean beaches, all the amenities you need if you are bringing kids! Love the simple decor, and loved the marked lack of nautical styling with cheap junk that overwhelmingly dominates this type of Airbnb rental everywhere!

Paradise! Laura’s place is a dream. Stroll your morning coffee to the beach every morning. Ride the bikes around this special place. Sleep with the sound of the waves through the bedroom window. This stylish, accommodating home has it all. Thanks Laura!

We absolutely loved our stay at Laura's! Literally 2 minutes to the beach which we loved. Incredible 'amentities' for children in her place as well (e.g. high chair, toys, crib, etc). We will definitely be coming back next summer! Thanks so much for the wonderful stay

Laura's Fair Harbor home is absolutely fabulous! Perfectly located near the Ferry and in between the ocean and the bay, she has all the amenities you'll need to have a wonderful stay. I couldn't recommend it more highly and we'd love to come back - it's really great!

Wonderful, cute house in a fantastic location. We had four people but the house could comfortably sleep 5 or 6. Very well-equipped kitchen. Great communication and helpfulness from Laura and excellent value too.

Laura’s house is the most charming cottage in the neighborhood! It is beautifully styled and very well appointed, filled with thoughtful touches and incredibly comfortable. We adored it inside and out. Both decks and the outdoor shower were really special and felt very private. The kitchen was really well stocked. The ocean is right there and the sweetest kids beach is 2 blocks away on the bay. Laura has a wagon and everything else you’d need to make the most of your stay.

We loved our stay at Carlo's place over a long holiday weekend in February. It was a lovely winter retreat. We especially enjoyed the hot tub, fireplace and interiors. The home is spacious and stylish as well as very comfortable! We felt right at home & were thankful that we could bring our dog along. The kitchen is very well stocked for the home cook. There is even an ice machine downstairs in the wet bar area. We had everything that we needed in order to make all meals. The weather was even warm enough to use the outdoor grill - there are 2 outdoor grills, both upstairs deck and downstairs! Happy Steer was a good butcher shop in the area. There are plenty of shops in the area (i.e. CVS within walking distance, driving distance for food stores, liquor stores, etc). It's probably best to have a car, but if you plan to hang at the house you may not need one. Just stock up well on a trip to the grocery store and uber/lyft around. We didn't check out the beach area since it was winter but it seems to be a short distance away. Check in was easy and instructions were clear. It was quiet & we slept well. We loved the home and thank you to Carlo! We look forward to future visits.

Great time, great place, every even slight problem I had was solved in a matter of hours. Will be back!

This house was amazing. It was perfect for myself any my colleague as we travelled for work. Carlo is amazing and so accommodating. I wish this could be my family weekend house. Hands down best host we have ever dealt with at airbnb!

This house provides exactly what my husband and I were looking for, a quiet, relaxing long weekend away with our pup. The house was nicely appointed and clean. We spent plenty of time by the fireplace. We would love to come back in warm weather to experience the pool at the house and beautiful beach nearby.

Comfortable, clean, and well appointed. Had a great stay. Carlo is really on his game as a host. The only thing better than staying here in the winter would be staying in the summer. This place will be on my list when I come back to the area.

Carlo's house was absolutely wonderful. Looks as good as it does in photos. the house is thoughtfully designed with ample amenities. We had some issues with the heat on the first day but Carlo was quick to help us resolve it. We would love to stay here again.

This home is beautiful in the pictures and even better in person. A picture never does a beautiful space like this justice . The hot tub was a nice bonus to our trip and the fire place downstairs was amazing. I have family all over Long Island on the eastern end so it was a convenient location for us to be able to visit with everyone.

We were very comfortable at Carlo's lovely home. We made nice memories there and so appreciated the thoughtful accomodations. I would book the home again excitedly!

This was our second time at Carmen’s house and it was as good as the first time. We would definitely stay here again and highly recommend her home.

Everything felt good at home

My daughter and I stayed at Carmen’s place over the Christmas holiday in order to be with family, and it was absolutely lovely. Warm, tastefully decorated, inviting, and with a great open-plan kitchen/living room, it is supplied with everything you need to cook and host wonderful meals during your stay. So many AirBnB’s these days are like vacant shells, but Carmen’s place is a true home. Plus, it’s a 5 minute drive to a beautiful, large ocean beach. We will definitely go back.

Excellently maintained. Highly recommend!

Carmen has a lovely home that we thoroughly enjoyed.

Loved the place so much I had to book TWICE . If you are looking for a very zen Long Island getaway , I HIGHLY recommend this home

This is a beautiful home! The decor inside and out is awesome. The home is very clean too! We love the location! Carmen is a terrific host with speedy responses! Thank you Carmen! We’re looking forward to next year!

Clean and cozy home

You will love this house! The layout is open and spacious. The pool and hot tub were huge bonuses after a great day on the best beaches on Long Island! The house was equipped with all your needs and is well appointed. You won’t want to book anything else after your stay here.

Best house I’ve ever stayed at in Fire Island!

The place was beautiful. The hot tub and pool were great extras!

Awesome place to stay! Everyone who works here is very accommodating and friendly!.

Easy to get to and perfect location.

Peter and his team at the Fire Island Hotel could not have been more responsive, patient, or accommodating. Thank you so much!

Morty is an extremely accommodating host who was so welcoming, even before we had booked the property and were just asking questions about it. The location is ideal if you have plans at both the pier and cherry grove. It's a beautiful property and though some of the rooms don't have A/C, it cools off quite nicely in the evening, even in the summer. Whenever we had a question, Morty was quick with an answer or solution--he always tried to make our stay as comfortable as possible. Will definitely come back here!

Wonderfully relaxing place that helps you truly enjoy Fire Island. Morty was so helpful and really wanted to make sure we had a fantastic stay. We’ll be back!

Had a great weekend at the property, check in was really easy, pool was lovely and all of the amenities were great! A place that feels like a welcoming home away from home. Thanks for having us!

As Dannii Minogue once sang, "you're perfection, you're all that I want"! A truly wonderful experience on the island staying at the most perfect home. We will be back! The Curious Raven loves Madonna's Erotica & Bedtime Stories, FYI :)

Beautifully private and secluded spot on Fire Island & great value. Morty was very communicative throughout our stay and was very accommodating. Highly recommended.

Morty is a great host. Lots of communication and checked in everyday to make sure if we needed anything. The pool is great and the house is very secluded. It is located at the very END of the boardwalk, so be prepared to walk it. The Master bedroom is the only room with an AC unit, the other 2 bedrooms have fans in them, as does the kitchen. The house was clean and had all the supplies you need.

This is such a beautiful, peaceful and scenic place. It's right on the edge of the a marsh, so we spent the whole week watching the birds and the wildlife (deer, etc.) who would pay us a visit. It's very private and very close to the beach. It's the absolute last house before you walk to Cherry Grove. The living space is nice but on the smaller side. The star of the show here is really the outdoor space. We were a couple with a baby and a grandma and while there weren't really other families around, this wasn't an issue for us. We would rent the same place again.

Morty’s house is an absolute dream!! The secluded location allows you to get some restful time by the pool and then you can just take the short walk into town (or Cherry Grove) to experience all the fun. Each bedroom has their own entrance to the pool deck which makes it great for everyone. Sitting by the pool or walking to beach means there is something for everyone. Morty was a really responsive host and super communicative the whole time. We had a great experience and hope to be back soon!!

Simply perfect. The true definition of a SUPER Host! The welcome binder made the stay even more fun. More dependable and personal than any hotel could be. The sunlight in the morning through the windows that are everywhere makes you just feel great.

This was our first time to the area so I speak with no authority when I say Chris's house feels like a quintessential Fire Island spot. That said, it was and I'd gladly return!

Perfect place for a fire island retreat

Christopher's home is the perfect Fire Island bungalow. We loved how mellow Ocean Bay Park was, but also an easy walk to restaurants and shops in Ocean Beach. The home itself was clean and cozy, and we loved sitting out the deck at night listening to the breeze blow through the bamboo. Christopher was also a pleasure to communicate with and super helpful with all our questions. We can't wait to return!

Very close to the beach, clean with a 60's surfer vibe. Enjoyed it very much!

Really great to chill out and relax in for a couple of days. Definitely plan to go back

Chris' house is in a great location. The house fits right into the Fire Island vibe, with its look and decor. We spent every day on the beach and almost every night in town at one of the many great bars and restaurants. Chris was eager to help us out with a local tip or to store our bags on the last day so we could enjoy the beach before heading home on the ferry. We will 100% be returning to the house. My only recommendation to other travelers is to save the good dates for us! Thanks so much Chris!

We loved this charming beach cottage with it's natural ventilation and low key attitude. For us this is just what a beach house should be, a place to relax and make good food while our 2-year old played. Would definitely go back!

A beautiful home with lovely touches. We couldn’t ask for a better place for our vacation. The house provided everything we need for our a week long stay including bicycles to ride around the town, a blender, games, books, beach chairs, and the rooftop was a big bonus. It’s a few minutes walk to the ocean, ferry service, and schooner inn. We had a power outage for a few hours and the staffs were amazing with their quick responses to the issues. Thanks so much!

Couldn’t imagine a more perfect spot for my family getaway. Close to the water and close to a restaurant, bar, and grocery story. Ferry drops you off nearly at the door. Wagons available to help you cart your things. Highly recommend staying here.

Perfect stay for a long weekend! Great location! Next to ferry, restaurants and beach!

The view of the bay is amazing and the sunset spectacular; the pool was also very comfortable and lovely... The hosts were accommodating and responsive. I look forward to returning!

Gracious hosts, relaxing environment with gorgeous bay views (sunset was particularly beautiful)! The location is in the heart of the Pines- very close to the beach and just under a mile walk to Cherry Grove. John and Ben went above & beyond and we really enjoyed visiting with them.

What a great place. I found the room to be charming and cozy. The room had a lot of the things you need to eat in the cabinets, including a toaster. Dylan wasn't there specificly to greet us, however the property owners were. They were very nice people and gave us all sorts of tips where to eat and where to go! We had a great time and would consider this place again.

Dylan’s place was fantastic. It’s located in a motel that’s kept up beautifully. The deck area outside the room is a perfect spot to sit outside and read in the morning or have a nightcap at night. I really can’t say enough good things about the vibe of this place. The location is on the bay side of the island, very close to where the Ocean Bay Park ferry drops you off. Bars/restaurants are more limited in Ocean Bay Park, so you’ll want to visit Ocean Beach (20 min. walk) for more selection. The best thing we did was rent bicycles so that we could zip back and forth to Ocean Beach and tour around all the side streets. Bikes are available for rent at the motel or if they run out, there’s a spot up the road with a huge selection. This was our first time on Fire Island and we can’t wait to go back next summer!

Perfect for a weekend on Fire Island!

Very fun and very comfortable would definitely recommend for anyone who is looking to stay in fire island, Dylan, Brett and Jeff were all great.

This place was really great for a few days getaway from nyc. We actually tried to tack another night onto our trip but it was already booked. The chairs, towels, and umbrellas come with the room, which was really handy. And the bikes were just a small rental fee. It was super handy having those in the motel gates. We grilled one of the nights, there were spices that would could use and fresh herbs in the garden. There were plates, utensils and cups for us to use. It really felt like it was a home away from home. Will come back!

We loved our stay at Dylan’s place. The complex is a welcoming community with such a relaxed atmosphere. The apartment itself was clean, comfy and had everything we needed.

This place was more than what I was expecting! Super clean, beautiful room and location. Plenty of complimentary amenities and the owners of the property were more than helpful and welcoming. Would definitely recommend to anyone looking to stay at Fire Island.

Great location, very comfortable Condo and the people who manage the day-to-day are very welcoming. This is a super way to enjoy Ocean Bay Park! Highly recommend staying at this Condo.

10 single beds, great for groups. Kitchen has everything you need, really cool inside living room. We used to deck to bbq and hangout which was great. They provided beach chairs and umbrella. They also had a wagon which made transporting stuff very easy. Would definitely stay here again!

Benjamin's house is in a great location! About 3 minutes walk from the Ocean Beach ferry, bars and restaurants and in the other direction about 3 minutes walk to the beach. Great house for groups. We grilled and hung out on the patio the entire time. Awesome summer weekend!

Perfect location, friendly host, good for a group!

This house was perfect for my large group. It was a walkable distance from the bars/restaurants and the beach. Ben was a great host and responded to me quickly. I would recommend this house to my friends!

Benjamin was an excellent host. He always gave me quick responses via the air bnb app if I had any urgent needs. I highly recommend this place because it had a perfect location between the beach and town. Our group had an amazing time and hope to return again next year.

We absolutely loved this place, it was prime location and such a lovely space for large groups. There were 10 twin sized beds and the house provided us with 4 beach chairs, an umbrella, and a cooler. We each had a bath towel and all the necessary amenities. Should we ever visit Ocean Beach again with a large group, will definitely try and stay here again. Benjamin was also great at responding right away. You cannot go wrong with this house!

Great location!

Highly recommend! 10 twin beds. Perfect for big groups. Great living area to hang. Host is extremely helpful and responsive. Seamless check in and checkout. Fire island is a strict island in general so make friends with the neighbors that can hear you when outside. They don’t like party groups but it’s the best island for a party group... ironic. Provides everything you need in the house. I would easily stay again. Thanks!

The location of this house was awesome-- just one house in from Ocean Beach. It was wonderfully quiet, yet an easy 12-min walk to town where we found good grocery stores, restaurants and shops. We saw deer and foxes on our walks. The house is nothing fancy but has all the essentials. Good for groups. We enjoyed the deck and outdoor shower.

Stephen was a great host, and so helpful in answering all our questions. He really knows how to welcome anyone to the island. We had a great time!

Great location - right on the beach and a very short walk into town. Stephen was a great host, quick to respond and always checking in to make sure we had everything we needed. The house was great for a large group and came with everything we needed for a great beach day (coolers, chairs, umbrellas, etc). Hope to come back next summer and would definitely stay here again!

Owners were dope

The place was better than expected with gorgeous location just a house away from the beach. The group I was with loved the area and the house everything was perfect and hopefully we’ll be back there soon for some more time.

Great bang for your buck especially if staying long term. Eoin is quick to respond no matter what the question is! Very helpful! House is beautiful with amazing waterfront views. 3 spacious bedrooms with everything you need for a great nights sleep. Kitchen is stocked well for cooking purposes & eating, bathrooms already had toilet paper & kitchen had paper towels so we didn’t have to worry & stop before we arrived. Plenty of things to do in the area while at the same time away from town and quiet. It really is a home away from home, would recommend 10/10.

Nice house, Eoin is a super keen person.

One of the best places to stay. I would stay again! Clean, spacious, and the view was really nice!

The house is spacious, clean, and has a bay view to die for. We especially enjoyed the deck and it comfortably for our group.

Nice place right by the water. Eoin will respond to messages quickly. Good place for a big family or group of friends and a good value. Thanks Eoin!

Eoin was a great host! House was very clean. Overall would 1000% visit again!

Great views. Rustic home with ample space. Full laundry. Well equipped kitchen. Three nice sized bedrooms and two full baths. Close to beaches. Convenient shopping located within a 10-15 minute drive.

2nd time we have stayed at one of Eoins places...never a disappointment!

Lydia is a wonderful host, and the cottage is very very close to gorgeous beaches! one thing: do remember to bring your linen closet with you (bathroom/beach towels), including a towel or bathroom rug to step onto when you get out of the shower.

Peters place was very beautiful, small cozy and could hold up to more than 10 people. Everything was so convenient, they had 4 bikes which was very helpful for us in exploring the island. Would definitely recommend. Would also like to remind people to bring their own towels. Thank you!

Peter and Lydia’s home is very centrally located, has a great back porch perfect for grilling and enjoying the weather. Very close to the beach and deli. Would strongly recommend!

We had a great stay at Peter and Lydia's Fire Island home! The house was a SUPER quick walk from the ferry and very close to the beach. We loved the outdoor space and how you could see the bay from the cute breakfast nook. We'll be back! :)

Perfect beach house! Close to the beach, restaurants and bars. House was spotless, exactly how listed and had great outside area for grilling and relaxing. Would highly recommend staying here.

My friends and I rented this house for a long weekend and couldn't have had a better experience. Peter and Lydia were super easy to get in touch with and answered all of our questions prior to arrival as well as during our trip. The house is super close to the ferry stop as well as a local market and in a great and fun part of Fire Island. It was the perfect size for a group of 10 especially considering it's two full bathrooms (plus an outdoor shower), large outdoor patio and living room spaces and a kitchen table that could comfortably seat all of us. We had the best time staying here and I'd definitely come back.

The place is exactly as described, great for a family/small group. I would definitely recommend it and stay there again!

Pete and Lydia are wonderful hosts. Their house is the perfect fire Island family beach home. Clean, great location, great space for a family! We enjoyed it so very much!

Great host, great house, great overall.

Nick went out of his way to make sure we had a wonderful stay! The home is very clean and comfortable and we really enjoyed it.

Such a great place to stay! The house was at the perfect temp when we got there. The house is so spacious and comfy

Let me start by saying Nicholas’s place is the definition oF SUPERHOST! Great communication and great house. I loved the location and just overall had a great getaway to go see a friend. Please do yourself a favor and book this place!!!

Great place to stay. Not far from the Hampton’s. Very spacious and clean. Hosts are quick to respond, very helpful, and nice!

Great place to rent!

We stayed here over the Christmas holiday and it was perfect for our family. It has a lot of common area with a lot of natural light. The neighborhood was very quiet and a quick drive to the beach where we took daily walks. The master bedroom has a nice office alcove that we could put our baby in so she had a semi private space. We will definitely return for our next gathering!

Wonderful stay great hospitality very comfortable and close to everything you need will come back 😊

Absolutely loved my experience here. Could not be happier with the location, the room, the hospitality - all of it! Will definitely stay here again when I'm in Fire Island.

Super helpful with check in. Clean room, friendly staff.

VERY highly recommended! This motel was the perfect way to take in Fire Island. The owners are so delightful and accommodating. Touches like renting bikes, offering beach chairs and umbrellas gratis, being willing to hold bags for the entire checkout day for a minimal fee all made staying there even easier!

Great location and amenities. Staff were extremely helpful and friendly. Would definitely come again!

Can not say enough great things about our stay. The room was immaculate, air conditioning worked great, and the bed was comfortable. This is a hard combination to find on Fire Island. The common areas were really nice to have, and the morning coffee was excellent. Having bike rentals available on site is a huge plus. Plenty of beach towels, chairs and umbrellas, as well. Hosts were very welcoming and quick to respond to any questions or concerns. Will definitely stay again!

We had a quick but wonderful stay thanks to the staff on hand- Jeff and Brett were awesome!

.....

Excellent. The place is very clean and the bed was among the most comfortable I have never slept on. The beach was a short walk away and having chairs and umbrellas for me to use was a great touch. It was about a 20 minute walk to Ocean Beach where the majority of restaurants are which was very pleasant. There are a few restaurants and bars in the immediate vicinity of the hotel. It was extremely quiet even with the windows open at night. We liked was quiet and salt even a bit secluded.