Holiday rentals in Anastasia Island

Find and book unique accommodation on Airbnb

Top-rated holiday rentals in Anastasia Island

Guests agree: these stays are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

%{current} / %{total}1 / 1
Guest favourite
Flat in St. Augustine Beach
4.92 out of 5 average rating, 201 reviews

Beachfront St. Augustine Condo • Pool, Ocean Views

Welcome to Turtle Trace, your beachfront getaway on Anastasia Island in beautiful St. Augustine! This condo offers direct pool & beach access, sweeping ocean views, and just minutes from Historic Downtown. Perfect for families, couples, or anyone wanting the ultimate coastal escape. Why You’ll Love It 🏖 Steps to the beach & pool right outside your patio door 🌅 Enjoy amazing sunrise views over the Atlantic 🏡 Gated, beautifully maintained community 🍴 Walk to restaurants, cafes & grocery stores

Top guest favourite
A modern kitchen is featured, showcasing sleek white cabinetry and a large island with seating for three. A stainless steel stove and hood are positioned centrally, complemented by minimalist decor. Natural light fills the space through a nearby glass door and staircase leading to the upper level.
Flat in St. Augustine
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 126 reviews

2BR/2B Get Away-Walk to St. Aug

This hidden gem (Unit B) is a 2 BR/2 bath home that is part of a duplex within a few minutes walk of some of the best St. Augustine has to offer and a short drive to St. Augustine Beach. The layout is perfect for a family/friends getaway, with the downstairs being comprised of the living area, kitchen, 1 BR, and 1 bath, and 1 additional BR and bath upstairs. 5-min bike ride to the beach, 5-min walk to all the bars and restaurants on Anastasia Blvd, and a 10-min walk(.6mi)to downtown St. Aug.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of the cottage is showcased, featuring a bright blue metal roof, white brick walls, and charming blue shutters. A patio with outdoor seating is visible, surrounded by lush greenery and palm trees under a colorful sunset sky.
Home in St. Augustine
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 292 reviews

Entire House w/ Backyard Hideaway - WALK TO BEACH

PARADISE ON PALMETTO: Unwind by the waves or at home in the backyard oasis. A true beach escape, we are nestled between the Atlantic Ocean & Intracoastal Waterway, walking distance to the beach and river. This bright, newly updated cottage is two blocks from the ocean and a 15 minute drive to the restaurants, bars, and attractions in Historic Downtown St. Augustine. Experience this ideal base to explore the Nation’s Oldest City! PARKING & WASHER/DRYER INCLUDED. SUPER CLEAN. NO CONTACT CHECK-IN.

Top guest favourite
A modern home with a distinctive triangular roof stands among lush greenery. A manicured lawn extends in front, bordered by palm trees. The building features a combination of light-colored siding and wooden accents, with a small balcony that adds to its architectural charm.
Home in St. Augustine
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Luxury Modern Home in Prime Location 2BDR-3BTH

Book your Spring Break vacation with us! Our contemporary home offers comfort, elegance, and curated amenities. Explore the historic downtown, climb the lighthouse, enjoy live performances, indulge in local cuisine, and relax on the nearby beach. The Lighthouse Beacon is the perfect retreat for families and friends, catering to all preferences. Experience the magic of Saint Augustine and create cherished memories. Book your stay now and let us be your guiding light in this captivating city.

Top guest favourite
A spacious deck overlooks a clear blue saltwater pool surrounded by lounge chairs and umbrellas. Lush greenery and palm trees frame the view of the water and dock area in the distance, creating a serene outdoor space for relaxation.
Cottage in St. Augustine
4.98 out of 5 average rating, 191 reviews

Perfect Waterfront Retreat w/Pool & Rooftop Deck

You've found your waterfront oasis tucked under the White Birds of Paradise! This spacious retreat was formerly a commercial art gallery. Two queen beds, one full bathroom & full kitchen make for comfortable living! You have a fenced path leading you down to the beautiful waters of Salt Run where a rooftop deck & salt water in-ground pool invites you to relax and slow down. Less than a mile to downtown St. Augustine, a little over a mile to the Amphitheater and about 3 miles to the beach.

Top guest favourite
A wooden walkway leads from a grassy area to the sandy beach, flanked by two benches on either side. The beach is visible in the distance, with gentle waves and a clear blue sky above.
Home in St. Augustine
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 292 reviews

St Augustine Beachside Home - Walk to Beach

Time to Relax at our St Augustine canal front getaway! Great family destination just 15 min. to Historic Downtown St Augustine. Neighborhood features PRIVATE Beach Access with a less than 10 minute . walk, depending on pace, to the Beach. Boating and Fishing at your Fingertips with private, over-the-water dock and ramp to floating dock where you can tie up your own boat/kayak/jet skis. The perfect end to your beachside dream day will be watching the sunset while on your private dock.

Top guest favourite
A screened-in porch showcases a relaxing atmosphere with wooden ceilings and large windows. A colorful hammock hangs beside a sofa and a blue coffee table, while natural light fills the space. Outdoor seating complements the inviting decor, surrounded by lush greenery.
Bungalow in St. Augustine
5 out of 5 average rating, 114 reviews

Tropical Bungalow Near Beaches, AMP & Downtown

Sea-Glass Bungalow Tropical Peaceful Retreat. All are welcome here! Feel your worries melt away as the tropical breeze rustles the private garden, enjoy unique features such as hanging hammocks & screened-in porch. This unique space has a style all its own. Artistic accents highlight this converted garage into a modern studio.. When you’re not relaxing in this tropical oasis, explore the Lighthouse, Alligator Farm & Bird Watching, White-Sand BCHs, The AMP & DWTN all this< 1mi away.

Top guest favourite
A view of the outdoor space showcases a paved patio area adjacent to the home. Two brightly colored chairs and two lounge chairs are positioned for relaxation. A privacy fence surrounds the yard, adorned with tropical greenery and palm trees.
Home in St. Augustine
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 179 reviews

Anastasia Steps to Downtown- Modern Island Home #A

Nestled in a serene residential area, this home offers a tranquil escape just a stroll across the Bridge of Lions to downtown. Enjoy convenient access, with various restaurants, shopping, and nightlife on A1A within a block. Ideal for large families, friends, or couples, the clean, modern space invites relaxation. Explore nearby attractions like miniature golf and the Alligator Farm and more. Leave the vehicle behind and enjoy an stress-free stroll to downtown, avoiding parking issues.

Top guest favourite
A light-filled living area is depicted, featuring a spacious couch positioned against a vibrant artwork of a clownfish. Sliding glass doors lead to a serene outdoor space, while colorful paintings adorn the walls, adding artistic charm to the room.
Guest suite in St. Augustine
4.99 out of 5 average rating, 492 reviews

Art Studio Space – Quiet – Walk to Beach

This very private studio apartment is on Anastasia Island, with its own entrance across the street to Anastasia State Park, which includes the St. Augustine Amphitheater in a quiet, friendly beach neighborhood. This ideal location is quite literally "a walk in the park" to a beautiful undeveloped Florida beach; or a 10 minute drive across the famous Bridge of Lions to historic downtown St. Augustine – with quick access to the many local attractions and great restaurants in the area.

Top guest favourite
Apartment in St. Augustine
4.9 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Sunrise Special | Steps to Beach | Ocean Front

Our OCEAN FRONT condo is just a short boardwalk to miles of beautiful beaches. Updated, modern, comfy living in this 2 bedroom condo w a balcony that allows generous views of the ocean! Features 2 pools (1 heated), 5 hot tubs, tennis courts, a pickle ball court, and bocci. Just 10 mins from the fabulous Old Town Historic District. Enjoy a spectacular sunrise with your morning coffee. Relax with the whole family at this peaceful place to stay. Must be 23 to rent.

Guest favourite
The entrance to St. Augustine Beach and Tennis Resort is showcased, featuring a prominent sign with the resort's name. Lush greenery surrounds the gated entrance, providing a welcoming and shaded look. The paved road leads into the community, flanked by well-maintained landscaping.
Townhouse in St. Augustine
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 279 reviews

St. Augustine Beach - A Townhouse Oasis!

GUESTS WHO STAY FOUR NIGHTS OR LONGER, WILL RECEIVE A REBATE ON THE HOUSEKEEPING FEE. Guest will discover a warm, inviting townhouse that aims to meet the needs of your vacation getaway. As hosts, we maintain and provide an up to date, comfortable, and convenient location to all the sites in the greater St. Augustine area; including a convenient 5-6 minute walk to the beach. ALSO, IF YOU LIKE YOUR PRIVACY you will enjoy our screened-in roof-covered lanai.

Top guest favourite
A dining area is featured with a blue table at its center, surrounded by four wooden chairs with woven seats. Natural light filters through bamboo shades on the windows, highlighting a wooden sideboard displaying beach-themed decor.
Home in St. Augustine
4.97 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

Perfect One Bedroom Cottage in Lighthouse Park

One bedroom one bath cozy cottage vibe! Perfect couples retreat. This is one half of a duplex. The second half is currently vacant. Excellent location. 5 blocks to the lighthouse. 1 mile to historic downtown. 1.3 miles to the Amphitheater. 0.8 miles to Anastasia State park. 3 miles to the St. Augustine Beach Pier. Walking distance to many great restaurants and bars, mini golf, and boutique shops! Walk or bike to downtown!

Popular amenities for Anastasia Island holiday rentals

Destinations to explore