House holiday rentals in Anastasia Island

Find and book unique houses on Airbnb

Top-rated house rentals in Anastasia Island

Guests agree: these houses are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1

Top guest favourite

A spacious waterfront deck offers lounge seating with blue cushions, set against a vibrant sunset sky filled with pink and orange hues. A hammock is positioned nearby, with palm trees framing the stunning view of the water and docks in the background.

Home in St. Augustine

5 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Fan Fave Waterfront: Lion’s Bridge & Old Town View

Our reviews set us apart. WE'D LOVE TO HOST YOU! Walk across the Bridge of Lions to downtown St. Augustine with amazing restaurants and attractions. A short walk to historic downtown, less than 1 mile to Castillo de San Marcos fort. Anastasia State Park Beach, the Alligator Farm and lighthouse are less than two miles away. Several restaurants and bars only a few blocks away. Whether going to the old fort or Flagler College, our home provides a great base for exploring an amazing part of Florida!

Top guest favourite

Home in St. Augustine

4.98 out of 5 average rating, 180 reviews

Uncle Reggie's Beach House

🏝️ Welcome 2026 Spring & Summer guests to your PRIVATE beach house! Walk to the beach, restaurants, arcade, coffee & yoga. 10min drive to historic downtown St. Augustine. Fenced yard, covered deck, grill, fire pit+ luxe outdoor shower. 3 bed/2 bath, sleeps 6. Kid/pet friendly. Modern kitchen. Remote workspace. 65" TV. ORIGINAL NINTENDO & 650+ games. 2 bikes, 2 chairs, + beach cart. Free coffee. Peaceful & quiet street yet close to everything. Always 5-star service hosted by hospitality pros! ✨

Top guest favourite

The sitting room features a blend of warm green and golden hues. A brown leather sofa is adorned with colorful pillows, complemented by a green accent chair. Sunlight filters through the white window blinds, illuminating a vibrant area rug and a piece of art depicting a pelican.

Home in St. Augustine

5 out of 5 average rating, 136 reviews

La Rêverie | Downtown Boutique, Historical Chic

Step inside La Rêverie, a distinguished 19th-century residence steeped in American heritage, meticulously restored & reimagined for today's discerning traveler. Centrally located on original coquina pillars, La Rêverie boasts cathedral ceilings suffused with sunlight and a bespoke French kitchen with chef-grade amenities. Invite guests to the sitting room, carefully designed to foster camaraderie. Choose from three plush bedrooms, each with an en-suite bath for a luxurious, yet private retreat.

Guest favourite

The living room is furnished with two light-colored sofas and a central coffee table, creating a spacious and inviting space. A decorative fireplace is framed by mirrors and artwork, while natural light filters in through shuttered windows and greenery adds a touch of nature.

Home in St. Augustine

4.94 out of 5 average rating, 221 reviews

Historic Designer Home • Luxury Baths • Steps2DWTN

Off Street Parking for 2 vehicles 2 Min. walk to St George St 5 Min drive to Anastasia State Park Beach 6 Min drive to Fitness Club/Pool High Speed Starlink Internet Luxury Retreat in Historic Downtown. Indulge in a charming vacation rental featuring a spacious living room, gourmet kitchen, and luxury baths. Immerse yourself in the rich history and vibrant culture, with its charming streets and local attractions. Whether seeking adventure or relaxation, this retreat offers the perfect base.

Top guest favourite

Home in St. Augustine

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 110 reviews

Anastasia Island Gem

Casa Coronado is an oasis close to all the action of beautiful St.Augustine. The Anastasia Island location offers the best of all worlds! A mile from the Alligator Farm, Lighthouse and the Anastasia State Park. More than a dozen eateries within a short walk. A short 3 mile drive to beautiful beaches and the pier. Walk over the Bridge of Lions and enjoy the downtown vibe with lots of shopping, dining, music and pubs. Lots of sightseeing and fun adventures within walking or biking distance.

Top guest favourite

A modern home with a distinctive triangular roof stands among lush greenery. A manicured lawn extends in front, bordered by palm trees. The building features a combination of light-colored siding and wooden accents, with a small balcony that adds to its architectural charm.

Home in St. Augustine

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 130 reviews

Luxury Modern Home in Prime Location 2BDR-3BTH

Book your Spring Break vacation with us! Our contemporary home offers comfort, elegance, and curated amenities. Explore the historic downtown, climb the lighthouse, enjoy live performances, indulge in local cuisine, and relax on the nearby beach. The Lighthouse Beacon is the perfect retreat for families and friends, catering to all preferences. Experience the magic of Saint Augustine and create cherished memories. Book your stay now and let us be your guiding light in this captivating city.

Guest favourite

A light-filled living area features a modern TV console with a large screen and decorative accents. The space includes a comfortable sofa, two armchairs, and a dining area with a table and chairs, seamlessly connecting to the fully equipped kitchen.

Home in St. Augustine

4.92 out of 5 average rating, 144 reviews

Sunshine by historic downtown & the beach

Welcome to Casa Sunshine! A charming home with 2 beds, 2 baths just by historic downtown and near stunning beaches. Fully stocked for cooking, sleeping, laundry & kids' fun. Enjoy beach gear and games, board and mini arcade games for those chill days. Explore historic landmarks, dining, & nightlife, all within walking distance. Unwind in the spacious comfy bedrooms with ample sleeping. Ideal for families or small groups. You'll for sure have an enjoyable and memorable stay in St. Augustine!

Top guest favourite

A wooden walkway leads from a grassy area to the sandy beach, flanked by two benches on either side. The beach is visible in the distance, with gentle waves and a clear blue sky above.

Home in St. Augustine

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 304 reviews

St Augustine Beachside Home - Walk to Beach

Relax at our St Augustine Canal-front getaway! Great family destination just 15 min. to Historic Downtown St Augustine. Neighborhood features PRIVATE Beach Access with about a 10 minute walk to the Beach. Boating and Fishing at your Fingertips with private, over-the-water dock and ramp to floating dock where you can tie up your own boat/kayak/jet skis. The perfect end to your beachside dream day will be watching the sunset while on your private dock.

Guest favourite

The exterior of a modern two-story home is displayed, featuring a mix of light and dark gray materials. A welcoming entrance is accessed by a set of stairs, with landscaped areas visible on both sides, including palm trees and shrubs.

Home in St. Augustine

4.95 out of 5 average rating, 105 reviews

192 Riberia Downtown Luxury Home

Summary: Located in historic Lincolnville neighborhood is this stunning luxury home perched along the tidal marshes of Oyster Creek and just steps from St. Augustine’s historic district. This unique home features a gourmet kitchen, an open living area with Netflix included, a handy workspace, 2 king bedrooms each with a full bath, queen memory foam sleeper sofa and stunning views out to the marsh from the custom windows and decked patio.

Top guest favourite

Aerial view of a home surrounded by lush greenery near a waterway, featuring a long dock extending into the water. The structure is illuminated, highlighting the inviting exterior against the twilight sky.

Home in St. Augustine

4.99 out of 5 average rating, 145 reviews

Gorgeous Views, Golf cart w/beach access!

Beautiful home with outstanding view & access to the Intracoastal. Watch dolphins play, yachts cruise by or catch the sunset from the dock. If you're feeling adventurous, jump on a kayak or paddle board & explore the quaint islands nearby. If the ocean is calling, take a 2 min ride with the included 6 seater golf cart (must sign waiver) & drive right on to Crescent beach. Grab a surf or boogie board for some extra excitement!

Top guest favourite

A dining area is featured with a blue table at its center, surrounded by four wooden chairs with woven seats. Natural light filters through bamboo shades on the windows, highlighting a wooden sideboard displaying beach-themed decor.

Home in St. Augustine

4.97 out of 5 average rating, 148 reviews

Perfect One Bedroom Cottage in Lighthouse Park

One bedroom one bath cozy cottage vibe! Perfect couples retreat. This is one half of a duplex. The second half is currently vacant. Excellent location. 5 blocks to the lighthouse. 1 mile to historic downtown. 1.3 miles to the Amphitheater. 0.8 miles to Anastasia State park. 3 miles to the St. Augustine Beach Pier. Walking distance to many great restaurants and bars, mini golf, and boutique shops! Walk or bike to downtown!

Top guest favourite

An open-concept living area features a comfortable gray sofa, a coffee table, and a TV on a stand. Natural light fills the space through the windows, and a dining table with chairs is visible in the background. A patterned rug adds warmth to the wooden floor.

Home in St. Augustine

4.96 out of 5 average rating, 369 reviews

Downton Abbottry 2/2 - 5 Min Walk To City Gates

Enjoy this charming 1910 Sears & Roe Buck catalog home that has been meticulously maintained home just a 5 minute walk to the City Gates and downtown. You have a private back patio space to enjoy coffee in the morning or a glass of wine in the evening. Or just take a leisurely stroll to many fine restaurants that St Augustine has to offer.