Guest house holiday rentals in Anastasia Island

Find and book unique guest house rentals on Airbnb

Top-rated guest house rentals in Anastasia Island

Guests agree: these guest house rentals are highly rated for location, cleanliness and more.

1 of 1 pages1 / 1
Guest favourite
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.91 out of 5 average rating, 363 reviews

10 Minutes to EVERYTHING!! Modern Serene Studio

Serene Studio is just that- a quiet, peaceful, private space to lay your head after exploring St. Augustine. Our 500 sq. foot studio cottage is detached from the main house, where we live. It's set in a residential neighborhood that runs along the Intracoastal Waterway (which makes for gorgeous morning or evening strolls). We're a 10 minute car ride (without traffic!!) to the historic downtown or St. Augustine Beach. Serene Studio is the best of both worlds without the noise, hustle and bustle!

Top guest favourite
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.96 out of 5 average rating, 111 reviews

Downtown cottage in perfect spot

An easy stroll to historic downtown St. Augustine’s shops, restaurants, trolleys, pubs, tourist hot spots and the country’s oldest fort. Only a 6-minute drive to the beach. Fully furnished, bright with ample windows & quaint. This guest house is on the same property - separated by an awesome courtyard - as an historic 1800s Victorian house. But you’ll have this entire cottage to yourself and it’s very private. Two bedrooms, each with a full-size bed & a large, comfortable couch in living room.

Top guest favourite
A compact kitchen area features wooden shelving displaying various ceramic bowls, pots, and decorative items. The full-size stove is positioned under a light fixture, with a dark sink and wooden countertop enhancing functionality. Artwork and plants add touches of decor above the counter.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.89 out of 5 average rating, 323 reviews

Tiny House three blocks from beach!

The tiny house at the Crescent Beach house is a one bedroom one bath detached guesthouse ! The bedroom includes a queen bed and closet. There is a great kitchen with a full size stove/oven, keurig, and microwave. Wifi and large smart tv for own subscriptions, no cable. Beach chairs, towels, and umbrella included! Soak in the great Florida beach lifestyle. There’s a board walk beach access at the end of the street ! This tiny house is adjacent to a two story home which is a separate Airbnb!

Guest favourite
A private cottage exterior features a deck with outdoor seating under an umbrella. Adjacent lounge chairs provide a place to relax. The structure is surrounded by grass and mature trees, with a small grill visible nearby.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 181 reviews

Island’s Edge Guest Cottage on Anastasia Island.

Fresh and professionally cleaned marsh front private cottage with amazing views. Walk or pedal from this adorable cottage to any of the local attractions. Nestled between the state park, our famous AMP, great beaches & downtown. Everything is close by. Your deck is perfect for a bbq, bird watching & sunset cocktails. ☹️Sorry no marsh access.☹️ Park trails and beach are close by. Stroll over to the Saturday morning market at “the Amp”. Ask me about our “Concert Package” You’ll love it here.

Top guest favourite
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 164 reviews

Historic Downtown Studio

Experience the charm and elegance of historic St. Augustine, Fl in our quaint carriage house. Located with in walking distance of many iconic landmarks, such as Flagler College, and the San Sebastián winery. Immerse yourself in the city culture, unique shops and dining scene. Whether you're seeking a romantic getaway or a cozy solo retreat, our carriage house offers a blend of comfort and convenience. Book your stay with us and experience the charm of this historic destination like a local.

Top guest favourite
The exterior of the casita features a gabled roof with large glass windows, allowing natural light to enter. Two double doors provide access, surrounded by lush green plants and palms. A covered entryway leads to the main entrance, enhancing the inviting appearance.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 446 reviews

The Garden Casita in St. Augustine Florida

Secluded garden casita tucked away three tenths of a mile from the city gates. Take the private garden pathway to serenity's doorstep, and gain access to WIFI, free parking, and a kitchenette equipped with the basic necessities. The zen garden serves as a wonderful resting space to relax and unwind from your day. The casita features a queen size bed with luxury linens, desk nook and a full bathroom. Come find your peace at the Garden Casita on the grounds of a 100 year old private home.

Top guest favourite
A tranquil outdoor space features a well-maintained heated pool surrounded by lush greenery and colorful flowers. Seating areas with black Adirondack chairs are positioned around the pool, offering a peaceful setting. A covered patio stands in the background, complementing the inviting atmosphere.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 203 reviews

Heated Pool Beach Bungalow Steps to the Ocean

Beautiful brand new in 2022 en-suite Bungalow beach side! Perfect for a romantic get a way or just one person, just 600 steps to the beach. Five minutes to the St Augustine pier and 10 minutes to the oldest city in the US, Historic Downtown St Augustine. Not only do you have the most comfortable bed to fall into, a 50" TV, recliners and an amazing heated pool. Beautiful beach sunrises, fishing, hiking, Concerts at the Amphitheater. For your safety you have an electronic keyless entry.

Superhost
The modern coastal apartment presents a bright exterior featuring blue and maroon accents. Lush greenery surrounds the pathway leading to the entrance, with a driveway providing ample parking space. The inviting atmosphere is enhanced by clear blue skies overhead.
Guest house in Butler Beach
4.86 out of 5 average rating, 125 reviews

Blues It Up - Beachside Studio Apartment

Located in Butler Beach this beautiful, modern, coastal efficiency apartment will accomodate 2 guests. Enjoy a short walk to the beach or drive on beach access just down the street. Close to restaurants and shopping. Butler Beach is located on Anastasia Island between Crescent Beach and St. Augustine Beach. Tones of Blue is a 2 bedroom 2 bath cottage on the property next door that is a seperate vacation rental. The garage is not included in the rental. Sorry, no pets or smoking

Top guest favourite
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.88 out of 5 average rating, 509 reviews

Coral Cottage Designer Studio•Walk/Bike 2 Downtown

Off Street Parking 4 Min Drive/ 15 Min Beautiful Walk to Historic Downtown 3 Min Drive to the Beach Guest Passes Fitness Club/Pool/Suana-Steam Rm/Yoga Looking to get away from the hustle & bustle of the city? This cottage surrounded by lush tropical garden is the perfect place to recharge. Downtown & the scenic beaches in Anastasia State Park are just a short drive away. With spacious living & modern amenities, the cottage offers maximum comfort & convenience.

Top guest favourite
The interior features an open living area with a light-colored sofa and a decorative cushion. A wall mural depicting a natural landscape is complemented by wooden beams overhead. A television is mounted on the wall across from a kitchenette with modern amenities.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.95 out of 5 average rating, 149 reviews

The Boathouse Studio on Anastasia Island

Welcome to The Boathouse, a stylish studio space surrounded by a tropical garden on Anastasia Island. The studio is a raised detached guest house with private parking, outdoor lanai space and alley entrance. Newly renovated space as of September 2023. The interior is perfect for couples or singles wanting a quiet and stylish stay close to everything St. Augustine has to offer.

Top guest favourite
The front entrance of a duplex is visible, featuring a light pink facade with decorative brick accents. A welcoming front door is framed by two potted plants with vibrant yellow flowers. A well-maintained lawn and a paved walkway enhance the inviting appearance of the home.
Guest house in St. Augustine
4.94 out of 5 average rating, 293 reviews

Sunset Casita

This is a duplex located off A1A in beautiful St. Augustine Beach. There is an oceanfront boardwalk to the beach nearby. Beach access by car is 2 blocks away. Publix, Winn Dixie and Starbucks are within walking distance as are many wonderful restaurants and shops. We are located five minutes from St. Augustine Amphitheater and 10 minutes to historic St. Augustine.

Top guest favourite
The private studio's exterior is framed by lush tropical plants and a high wooden fence, providing seclusion. A vibrant yellow door invites entry, while potted plants decorate the entrance. Two beach bikes are positioned nearby, ready for use on outdoor adventures.
Guest house in St. Augustine
5 out of 5 average rating, 176 reviews

"Conch Cabana" a retro studio with tropical vibes!

* Peaceful end of Anastasia Island * One block walk to intracoastal for a local sunset experience * Easy beach access... walk/bike or 4wheel drive * 15 minute drive to downtown St. Augustine * 10 minute drive to The Amp * Private detached studio with your own enclosed courtyard * 2 beach bikes available to use .

Popular amenities for guest house rentals in Anastasia Island

Destinations to explore