Monthly Rentals in South Bass Island

Stayed for a weekend with a group of friends. None of us had ever been to Put in Bay, and staying here was the perfect choice. It is walkable but still private, and the staff were very friendly and helpful.

My husband and I enjoyed our stay at the Toledo House and will most definitely be booking again in the future! My only recommendation would be to put in the Airbnb description that there are private entrances and bathrooms for all units, as well as hot water. There was some confusion and I ended up reaching out to Skip for clarification before our stay. The location was great! The room was extremely clean and we heard no noise whatsoever from the neighbors. As I said, we will be staying here again!

She was extremely responsive and helped out anyway she could unfortunately it rained while we were there, but she was still able to make it a wonderful time. Definitely would recommend her and her husband are amazing!

We’ve visited Put In Bay every summer for close to 30 years, and this is hands-down our favorite rental. The home was perfect for our family, with stunning views of the water, and close to everything the village has to offer. We’re already planning for next year,