Holiday rentals in Cicero

Barely A Wake House

Welcome to Barely A Wake House @ Lakeside Bluffs! Come stay seconds from Morse Reservoir in this beautifully built 2025 lake home! A gorgeous second story balcony overlooks the beautiful sunsets on Morse Reservoir. Whether you're bringing your family in town for leisure and want to spend some time on the water or here for extended stays in Indy for business, this is one of the most elegant and glamorous stays that you can find in Hamilton County! A close drive to Grand Park, Ruoff, and Indy!

Downtown Noblesville Carriage House

Perfectly located two blocks from Downtown Noblesville in one of the beautiful Historic Neighborhoods. Private parking for one car, open, airy space with full kitchen, living room, two bedrooms and two baths. Full remodel on this carriage house was completed in October 2017. Everything is brand new. Walking distance to parks, golf courses, gym, restaurants, shopping, grocery, antique stores, city buildings, and a museum. 15 minutes form Klipsh Music Center and 35 minutes from downtown Indy.

Comfortable Lakeview Retreat/Close to GRAND PARK

Escape to our Cozy Lakeside Getaway! This beautifully updated home features inviting beds and a fully equipped kitchen. Located on a quiet street near the lake, it’s a 5-minute walk to favorite Cicero spots like 10 West, Boathouse, DeLullo's, and Alexander’s Ice Cream. It's also just a quick drive to shopping and adventures. Perfect for up to 6 adults. Embrace the charming small-town and golf cart community of Cicero and unwind in this spotless retreat.15 minutes from GRAND PARK sports complex!

The Cozy Cottage

Enjoy a relaxing getaway in this cozy cottage. Historic Downtown Noblesville is just a short walk where you will find great restaurants, pubs, and boutique shops. The cottage consists of one bedroom, a fully equipped kitchen, and a full bathroom with walk-in shower. There’s also a fenced backyard with fire pit and furniture. The Cozy Cottage is centrally located near downtown Noblesville (2 min), Ruoff Music Center (15 min), Grand Park Sporting Complex (20 min), and over 100 miles of trails.

Spacious Stay w/Game Room

Bring the whole family to this great place with lots of room for fun. Welcome to your Westfield getaway! Just minutes from Grand Park and Chatham Hills, this modern home features a king suite, spacious living areas, and a one-of-a-kind game room—complete with ping pong, sports games, and more. Perfect for families, teams, or group trips. Enjoy fast Wi-Fi, smart TVs, a fully stocked kitchen, and cozy touches throughout. Whether you're here to relax or compete, this is your home base for fun!

Adorable cottage walking distance to Morse Lake

10 minute walk to Morse Lake and sleeping 7, this fully loaded modern cottage has everything you need for convenience and fun -- full kitchen, gas grill, private outdoor space, and (with advanced notice) you can park your boat in the driveway. 5 minute walk from restaurants and charming downtown Cicero, . Downtown Noblesville, Ruoff, Grand Park and Connor Prairie are a short, 20 minute drive away. Great Central Indiana location -- 40 minutes to downtown Indy and only 30 minutes to Kokomo!

Lakehouse Oasis on Morse Reservoir—Private Getaway

The Lakehouse Oasis overlooking beautiful Morse Reservoir is perfect for families and large groups (Sleeps 14). Enjoy backyard waterfront access with a private dock to swim, fish, and boat from. Our open floor plan home has stunning waterfront views so get ready for an epic sunrise every morning! Morse reservoir is an all-sports lake with no shortage of attractions including boating, golfing, hiking, shopping, and of course dining. *Sports families we are 15 minutes away from Grand Park.

Backwoods Forest Retreat

(3) Twin Bunks sleep 6 plus (2) Queens. Huge 16x20 Patio with Firepit to enjoy chirping frogs and peaceful evenings 1/4mi back in the Forest. Our property backs up to a 15ac Nature Preserve and we have no nearby neighbors. Property Owner, Me, lives at the home, but is separated by a locked door. On the opposite side there is a Studio AirBnB and in the front of the house toward the treeline there are RV travelers who sometimes camp out. Very Private. Good times encouraged.

Riverfront Hideaway/Fishing/Pet‑Friendly/Views!

Welcome to @WhiteRiverCasita - a cozy getaway minutes from historic downtown Noblesville and Koteewi Park - enjoy a breathtaking slide down Koteewi Run, Indianapolis’ best and only snow tubing hill! This hidden 1-bedroom, 1-bath gem features a large deck overlooking the river with comfortable furniture for dining and enjoying the outdoors. You’ll love the peaceful surroundings but there’s also plenty to do nearby, including kayaking, hiking, golfing, shopping and more.

Comfy home, near Grand Park, & Ruoff Music Center.

Enjoy the best of Cicero from this charming, dog friendly home at 169 Washington Ave. Walk to local restaurants and a coffee shop, or take a short stroll two blocks to Morse Lake for boating, fishing, and sunsets. Plenty of parking—including space for a truck and boat trailer—makes lake days easy. Close to parks and just minutes from Deer Creek (Ruoff) Music Center and Grand Park, Westfield, IN. Boat by day, dine by night, and relax in comfort.

Historic 2 Bedroom House in Downtown Arcadia

Our newly remodeled and furnished historic 2 Bedroom, 1 bath, house is located in the heart of downtown Arcadia! With all the essentials of home, you can relax whether you are in town for just the weekend or even more of a long term stay. Come enjoy “Where Small Town America Still Exists”, and be footsteps away from our local restaurants, brewery and our Summer Thursday farmer’s market.

Cumberland Cottage

The Cumberland Cottage is ideal for couples, families, or groups of friends exploring the area. Featuring cozy accommodations and a prime location, visitors are guaranteed a delightful experience. The property sits right next to a lovely church, and while it is situated in the city close to various amenities, it uses well water, making it suitable for those sensitive to municipal water.